Slovo.ru: Baltic accent

2020 Vol. 11 № 4

Back to the list Download an article

Argumentum ad morti in the violence discourse: the semantics and pragmatics of ‘radical’ argumentation

DOI
10.5922/2225-5346-2020-4-5
Pages
58-64

Abstract

The appeal to death is a type of argument that either explicitly or implicitly invokes hu­man finitude. This rhetorical device contributes to the credibility of requests, wishes, etc., or blocks communication. The illocutionary power of the appeal to death is determined by the means it uses, which range from inductive generalisation and deductions to approaching the limit of this generalisation, to the threat of going beyond the existential boundaries of the dis­course, to the problem domain losing its existential status, and to the threat being carried out. All of them make communication insignificant and the subject, or even the opponent, non-existent. This style of argumentation is peculiar to ‘pre-logical’ communities where the logical culture of social communication is underdeveloped and unwanted, where an instrumental appeal is made not to the law but force, not to freedom but arbitrariness.

Reference

  1. Kurbatov, V., 1993. Zhenskaya logika [Women's logic]. Rostov-on-Don (in Russ.).

  2. Povarnin, S. I., 1997. Spor. O teorii i praktike spora [Dispute. On the theory and practice of the dispute]. St. Petersburg (in Russ.).

  3. Tulchinskii, G. L. and Epshtein, M. N., 2003. Proektivnyi filosofskii slovar'. Novye ter­miny i ponyatiya [Philosophical Dictionary. New terms and concepts]. St. Peters­burg (in Russ.).

  4. Tulchinskii, G. L., 2010. Kul'tura delovoi i politicheskoi argumentatsii [Culture of bu­si­ness and political reasoning]. St. Petersburg (in Russ.).

  5. Tulchinskii, G. L., 1992. Mechanical argument. Filosofskaya i sotsiologicheskaya mysl' [Phi­losophical and sociological thought], 11, pp. 108—112 (in Russ.).

  6. Tulchinskii, G. L., 1995. Argumentum ad morti. Vestnik Sankt-Peterburgskogo uni­ver­siteta. Ser. 6 [Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University. Ser. 6], 1, pp. 10—14 (in Russ.).

  7. Chueshov, V. I., 1993. The Argument to Death: Logic, Rhetoric and Dialectics of Communication. In: A. V. Demichev and M. S. Uvarov, eds. Tema smerti v dukhovnom opyte chelovechestva [The Topic of Death in the Spiritual Experience of Humanity]. St. Pe­tersburg. pp. 10—12 (in Russ.).

  8. Quine, W. V., 1981. Theories and things. Cambridge.