2025 Vol. 16 №2

“Rhetorical question” in linguistics and speech

DOI

10.5922/2225-5346-2025-2-3

Pages

53-70

Abstract

The article examines the concept of the rhetorical question, which — quite surprisingly — is still not part of the standard and widely recognized inventory of linguistic categories, and the term ‘rhetorical question’ is rarely used in linguistic studies. At the same time, the ex­pres­sion ‘rhetorical question’ is actively employed in discourse, and, at first glance, seems to be used in a rather broad and undefined sense. The goal of this article is to distinguish between the­se two fields: linguistics and everyday speech. On the one hand, the concept of a rhetorical question is given a clear definition, allowing the term to be introduced into the linguistic framework, and on the other hand, the actual usage of this expression in discourse is desc­ribed. It is shown that the general principle of using the word ‘rhetorical’ in discourse in relation to a question is that this question is ‘not genuine’ in some way, i. e. it is a question that is not being asked in order to get the answer. To characterize a question as rhetorical, two parameters are significant: “Why does this question not require an answer?” and “For what purpose is this statement being made, if not to get an answer?” By calling (his own or so­meo­ne else's) question ‘rhetorical’, the speaker indicates the implementation of one of the values of these parameters.

Reference

Arutyunova, N. D., 1998. Yazyk i mir cheloveka [Language and the Human World]. Moscow (in Russ.).

Bulygina, T. V. and Shmelev, A. D., 1997. Yazykovaya kontseptualizatsiya mira (na materiale russkoi grammatiki) [Linguistic Conceptualization of the World (based on the material of Russian Grammar)]. Moscow (in Russ.).

Dobrovolskij, D. O. and Zalizniak, Anna A., 2025. Rhetorical question as a com­mu­ni­cative act. Voprosy Jazykoznanija [Topics in the study of language], 1, рр. 7—35, https://doi.org/10.31857/0373-658X.2025.1.7-35 (in Russ.).

Dobrovolskij, D. O. and Zalizniak, Anna A., 2022. On the notion of a rhetorical question. In: L. Iomdin, J. Milićević and A. Polguère, eds. Wiener Slawistischer Alma­nach. Linguistische Reihe, Sbd. 101. Berlin, pp. 139—146.

Kwiatkowski, A., 1966. Poeticheskii slovar' [A Poetic Dictionary]. Moscow (in Russ.).

Lingvisticheskii entsiklopedicheskii slovar' [Encyclopedic Dictionary of Linguistics], 1990. Moscow (in Russ.).

Meibauer, J., 1986. Rhetorische Fragen. Tübingen.

Mostovaya, L. A., 2009. Rhetorical question in groups of indirect speech acts. Russian Language Studies, 4, pp. 39—45 (in Russ.).

Paducheva, E. V., 2013. Russkoe otritsatel'noe predlozhenie [Russian negative sen­ten­ce]. Moscow (in Russ.).

Searle, J., 1969. Speech Acts: An Essay in the Philosophy of Language. Cambridge, 212 p.

Sharonov, I. A., 2021. The formation of communicatives on the basis of rhetorical questions. Cuadernos de Rusística Española, 17, pp. 53—66, https://doi.org/10.30827/ cre.v17.20929 (in Russ.).

Shvedova, N. Yu., ed.,1980. RG-80 — Russkaja grammatika. T. II. Sintaksis [Russian grammar. Vol. 2. Syntax]. Moscow (in Russ.).

Vendler, Z., 1976. Illocutionary suicide. Issues in the Philosophy of Language, pp. 135—145.

Vendler, Z., 1985. Illocutionary suicide. In: Novoe v zarubezhnoi lingvistike [New in foreign linguistics]. Iss. 16. Moscow, pp. 238—250 (in Russ.).

Zalizniak, Anna A., 2024. The Russian interrogative particle razve: the pragmati­ca­li­zation path. In: Graf, E. and Schweier, U., eds. Pragmaticalization: Language Change bet­ween Text and Grammar. Berlin; Boston, pp. 375—391.