2024 Vol. 43. №3

Kantian and Anti-Kantian Philosophy of Language

DOI

10.5922/0207-6918-2024-3-4

Pages

47-80

Abstract

This paper examines two models of language philosophy. The first is the Kantian philosophy which sees language as an instrument of conveying mental content. I have selected Immanuel Kant and Edmund Husserl from amongst its numerous representatives. In this tradition, a language expression, i.e. an expression that has meaning, is determined by the objectively ideal character of the meanings (“rules”) given through the subject’s intellectual acts. The main task is to fix with a maximum degree of accuracy what is “seen” in consciousness. This model inevitably considers words to be “markers” or “labels” which have no intrinsic power. The problem with this approach is, first, that it is impossible to determine the criteria by which this or that word should be considered adequate. Second, this approach leads to the creation of ever new philosophical languages which simultaneously challenge the tradition and yet claim to be a renewed version of it. It is shown that the fairly systematic critique of the Kant­ian approach by Johann Georg Hamann and Johann Gottfried Herder falls short of proposing an alternative philosophical system because, having a religious foundation, it does not offer a complete grounding of knowledge. In the wide range of anti-Kantian positions on the nature of language Gustav Shpet’s concept of language is singled out. It pursues the same task of creating a universal system of knowledge as Husserl’s phenomenology, but it proceeds from fundamentally different notions of philosophical knowledge. Unlike Husserl, whose thought is marked by revolutionary radicalism, for Shpet ideal knowledge is “positive”, “concrete”, “full” and “dynamic”. He considers philosophising to be dialectical and inherently dialogic. The result of philosophy meeting these ideals is the concept that our knowledge is centred on language and our experience has a sign-verbal character.

Reference

Alexander, W. M., 1966. Johann Georg Hamann: Metacritic of Kant. Journal of the History of Ideas, 27(1), pp. 137-144.

Burge, T., 1992. Philosophy of Language and Mind: 1950—1990. The Philosophical Review, 101(1), pp. 3-51.

Cloeren, H. J., 1988. Language and Thought: German Approaches to Analytic Philosophy in the 18th and 19th Centuries. Berlin: Walter de Gruyter.

Dummett, M., 1973. Frege: Philosophy of Language. London: Duckworth.

Dummett, M., 1993. Origins of Analytical Philosophy. London: Duckworth.

Forster, M. N., 2010. After Herder. Philosophy of Language in the German Tradition. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Forster, M. N., 2012. Kant’s Philosophy of Language? Tijdschrift voor Filosofie, 3, pp. 485-511.

Hamann, J. G., 1999. Metakritik über den Purismum der Vernunft. In: J. G. Hamann, 1999. Sämtliche Werke. Nachdruck der historisch-kritischen Ausgabe von J. Nadler. Volume 3: Schriften über Sprache, Mysterien. Ver­nunft: 1772—1788. Wuppertal; Tübingen: Brockhaus, 1999, pp. 281-289.

Hamann, J. G., 2007. Metacritique on the Purism of Reason. In: J. G. Hamann, 2007. Writings On Philosophy and Language History of Philosophy. Translated by K. Haynes. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 205-218.

Hegel, G. W. F., 1977. Phenomenology of Spirit. Translated by A. V. Miller. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Husserl, E., 1970. The Crisis of European Sciences and Transcendental Phenomenology. An Introduction to Phenomenological Philosophy. Translated by D. Carr. Evanston: Northwestern University Press.

Husserl, E., 1976a. Ideen zu einer reinen Phänomenologie und phänomenologischen Philosophie. Erstes Buch: Allgemeine Einführung in die reine Phänomenologie. 1. Halbband. Text der 1.-3. Auflage. Edited by K. Schuhmann. In: Husserliana. Edmund Husserl Gesammelte Werke. Volume III/1. Dordrecht: Kluwer.

Husserl, E., 1976b. Die Krisis der europäischen Wissenschaften und die transzendentale Phänomenologie. Eine Einleitung in die phänomenologische Philosophie. Edited by W. Biemel. In: Husserliana. Edmund Husserl Gesammelte Werke. Volume VI/2, verbesserte Auflage. Den Haag : Nijhoff.

Husserl, E., 1983. Ideas Pertaining to a Pure Phenomenology and to a Phenomenological Philosophy. First Book: General Introduction to a Pure Phenomenology. In: Husserliana: Edmund Husserl – Collected Works. Volume 2. Dordrecht: Nijhoff.

Husserl, E., 1984. Logische Untersuchungen. Buch 2: Untersuchungen zur Phänomenologie und Theorie der Erkenntnis. T. 1. Herausgegeben von U. Panzer. In: Husserliana. Edmund Husserl Gesammelte Werke. Volume XIX/1. Dordrecht: Kluwer.

Husserl, E., 1986. Aufsätze und Vorträge (1911—1921). Herausgegeben von Th. Nenon und H.-R. Sepp. In: Husserliana. Edmund Husserl Gesammelte Werke. Volume XXV. Dordrecht: Kluwer.

Husserl, E., 1996. Logik und allgemeine Wissenschaftstheorie. Vorlesungen 1917/18, mit ergänzenden Texten aus der ersten Fassung 1910/11. Herausgegeben von U. Panzer. In: Husserliana. Edmund Husserl Gesammelte Werke. Volume XXX. Dordrecht: Kluwer.

Husserl, E., 2001a. Logical Investigations. Investigations into Phenomenology and the Theory of Knowledge. Part 1. Volume II, Part I of the German Editions. In: E. Husserl, 2001. Logical Investigations. With a new preface by M. Dummett and edited with a new Introduction by D. Moran. London: Routledge, pp. 163-313.

Husserl, E., 2001b. Logical Investigations. Investigations into Phenomenology and the Theory of Knowledge, Part 3-4, Volume II. In: E. Husserl, 2001. Logical Investigations. With a new preface by M. Dummett and edited with a new Introduction by D. Moran. London: Routledge.

Husserl, E., 2012. Ideas Pertaining to a Pure Phenomenology and to a Phenomenological Philosophy. First Book: General Introduction to a Pure Phenomenology. New foreword by D. Moran, translated by W. R. Boyce Gibson. London & New York: Routledge.

Husserl, E., 2019. Logic and General Theory of Science. Translated by C. O. Hill. In: Husserliana: Edmund Husserl — Collected Works, Volume XV. Berlin: Springer.

Kant, I., 1992. Lectures on Logic. Translated and edit­ed by J. M. Young. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Kant, I., 1998. Critique of Pure Reason. Translated and edited by P. Guyer and A. Wood. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Kant, I., 1999. Correspondence. Translated and edited by A. Zweig. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Kant, I., 2002. Critique of Practical Reason. Translated by W. S. Pluhar, Introduction by S. Engstrom. Indianapolis & Cambridge: Hackett Publishing Company.

Kant, I., 2007a. Critique of Judgement. Translated by J. C. Meredith; revised, edited and introduced by N. Walker. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Kant, I., 2007b. Anthropology from a Pragmatic Point of View. Translated by R. B. Louden. In: I. Kant, 2007. Anthropology, History, and Education. Edited by G. Zöllner, R. B. Louden. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 227-429.

Kant, I., 2009. Religion within the Bounds of Bare Reason, translated by W. S. Pluhar, introduction by S. R. Palmquist. Indianapolis & Cambridge: Hackett, 2009.

Kusch, M., 1989. Language as Calculus vs. Language as Universal Medium. A Study in Husserl, Heidegger and Gadamer. Dordrecht & London & Boston: Kluwer.

Maimon, S., 1791. Philosophisches Wörterbuch, oder Beleuchtung der wichtigsten Gegenstände der Philosophie, in alphabetischer Ordnung. Berlin: bei Johann Friedrich Unger.

Mikhailov, A. A., 2009. Toward a Forgotten Polemic: Hamann versus Kant. In: M. A. Solopova and M. F. Bykova, eds. 2009. Sushchnost’ i slovo: sbornik nauchnykh statei k jubileyu professora N. V. Motroshilovoi [Essence and Word: A Collection of Scientific Papers for the Anniversary of Professor N. V. Motroshilova]. Moscow: Fenomenologiya-Germenevtika, pp. 293-304. (In Rus.)

Plato, 1997. Letters. In: Plato, 1997. Complete Works, ed. by J. M. Cooper, D. S. Hutchinson. Indianapolis: Hackett, pp. 1634-1676.

Schleiermacher, F. D. E., 2002. Vorlesungen über die Dialektik. Teilband 2. Edited by A. Arndt. In: F. D. E. Schleiermacher, 2002. Kritische Gesamtausgabe. Zweite Abteilung: Vorlesungen. Volume 10, Part 2. Berlin: de Gruyter.

Shchedrina, T. G., 2008. Arkhiv epokhi. Tematicheskoe edinstvo russkoi filosofii [Archive of the Epoch. The Thematic Unity of Russian Philosophy]. Moscow: ROSSPEN. (In Rus.)

Shchedrina, T. G., 2010. Gustav Speth as a Philosopher of Science: The Experience of Antidogmatic Teaching. In: G. G. Shpet, 2010. Filosofiya i nauka [Philosophy and Science]. Edited by T. G. Shchedrina. Moscow: ROSSPEN, pp. 5-16. (In Rus.)

Shpet, G. G., 1989. Esteticheskie fragmenty [Aesthetic Fragments]. In: G. G. Shpet, 1989. Works. Moscow: Pravda, pp. 343-472. (In Rus.)

Shpet, G., 1991. Appearance and Sense. Phenomenology as the Fundamental Science and Its Problems. Translated by T. Nemeth. Dordrecht & Boston & London: Kluwer.

Shpet, G. G., 2005. Language and Sense. In: G. G. Shpet, 2005. Mysl’ i Slovo. Izbrannye trudy [Thought and Word. Selected works]. Edited by T.G. Shchedrina. Moscow: ROSSPEN, pp. 470-668. (In Rus.)

Shpet, G. G., 2007. Aesthetic Fragments. In: G. G. Shpet, 2007. Iskusstvo kak vid znaniya. Izbrannye trudy po filosofii kul’tury [Art as a Form of Knowledge. Selected Works on Philosophy of Culture]. Edited by T. G. Shchedrina. Moscow: ROSSPEN, pp. 173-322. (In Rus.)

Shpet, G. G., 2008. Ocherk razvitiya russkoi filosofii. I [An Outline of the Development of Russian Philosophy. Part 1]. Edited and commented by T. G. Shchedrina. Moscow: ROSSPEN. (In Rus.)

Shpet, G. G., 2014. Istorija kak problema logiki: Kri­ticheskie i metodologicheskie issledovanija. Chast’ pervaja. Materialy [History as a Problem of Logic: Critical and Method­ological Studies. Part One: Materials]. Edited and commented by T. G. Shchedrina. Moscow & St. Petersburg: Universitetskaja kniga. (In Rus.)

Shpet, G., 2019. Philosophy and History. In: G. Shpet, 2019. Hermeneutics and Its Problems. With Selected Essays in Phenomenology. Edited and translated by T. Nemeth. Cham: Springer, pp. 269-277.

Waxman, W., 2005. Kant and the Empiricists: Understanding Understanding. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Wittgenstein, L., 2009. Philosophical Investigations. Translated by G. E. M. Anscombe, P. M. S. Hacker and J. Schulte. Revised Fourth Edition by P. M. S. Hacker and J. Schulte. Oxford: Blackwell Publishing.