Аналитическая философия, ее история и Кант
- DOI
- 10.5922/0207-6918-2013-2-5
- Страницы / Pages
- 56-68
аналитическая философия
история философии
анализ языка
лингвистический поворот
философия Канта
analytic philosophy
history of philosophy
analysis of language
linguistic turn
Kant’s philosophy
Аннотация
Рассматриваются современные дискуссии относительно истории аналитической философии, критериев ее выделения как философского направления и ее современного статуса. Подчеркивается, что для понимания аналитической философии важно учитывать ее амбивалентное отношение к философии Канта.
Abstract
The paper is devoted to the contemporary discussions about the history of analytic philosophy, the criteria of its distinguishing as a philosophical movement and its present status. It is emphasized that its ambivalent attitude to Kant’s philosophy is important for understanding the character of analytic philosophy.
Список литературы
1. Брюшинкин В. Н. Логика Канта и метафизика Стросона // Кантовский сборник. 2011. Вып. 3. С. 7—17.
2. Вригт Г. Х. фон. Аналитическая философия: историко-критический обзор / пер. с англ. Л. Б. Макеевой // Кантовский сборник. 2013. Вып. 1 (43). С. 78—89; 2 (44). С. 69—81.
3. Грязнов А. Ф. Феномен аналитической философии в западной культуре ХХ столетия // Вопросы философии. 1996. № 4. С. 37—47.
4. Кант И. Собр. соч.: в 6 т. М., 1965. Т. 4, ч. 1.
5. Макеева Л. Б. Язык, онтология и реализм. М., 2011.
6. Чалый В. А. Питер Стросон об аналитическом, синтетическом и априорном // Рацио.ru: электронный научный журнал. 2010. Вып. 3.
7. Cohen J. L. The dialogue of reason: an analysis of analytical philosophy. Oxford, 1986.
8. Glock H.-J. What is analytic philosophy? Cambridge, 2008.
9. Dummett M. Origins of analytic philosophy. L., 1993.
10. Føllesdal D. Analytic philosophy: what is it and why should one engage in it? // The Rise of Analytic Philosophy / ed. by H.-J. Glock. Oxford, 1997. P. 193—208.
11. Hacker P. The rise of twentieth century analytic philosophy // The Rise of Analytic Philosophy / ed. by H.-J. Glock. Oxford, 1997. P. 51—76.
12. Hanna R. Kant and the foundations of analytic philosophy. Oxford, 2001.
13. Kemp S. N. Commentary to Kant’s “Critique of Pure Reason”. 2nd edn. Atlantic Highlands, 1992.
14. Monk R. What is analytical philosophy? // Bertrand Russell and the origins of analytic philosophy / ed. by R. Monk, A. Palmer. Bristol, 1996. P. 1—23.
15. Idem. Was Russell an Analytic Philosopher? // The Rise of Analytic Philosophy / ed. by H.-J. Glock. Oxford, 1997. P. 35—50.
16. Pap A. Elements of analytical philosophy. N.Y., 1949.
17. Preston A. The implications of recent work in the history of analytic philosophy // Bertrand Russell Society Quarterly. 2005. № 125.
18. Price H. H. Hume’s theory of the external world. Oxford, 1940.
19. Putnam H. Realism with a human face. Cambridge, 1990.
20. Rorty R. Philosophy and the mirror of nature. Princeton, 1979.
21. Ryle G. Taking sides in philosophy // Collected Essays. L., 1971. Vol. 2. P. 153—169.
22. Searle J. Contemporary philosophy in the United States // The Blackwell Companion to Philosophy / ed. N. Bunnin, E. P. Tsui-Lames. Oxford, 1996. P. 1—24.
23. Soames S. Philosophical analysis in the twentieth century. Princeton, 2003. Vol. 1, 2.
24. Story of analytic philosophy: plot and heroes / ed. by A. Biletzki, A. Matar. L., 1998.
25. Stroll A. Twentieth-century analytic philosophy. N.Y., 2000.
26. Talisse R. B., Scott F. A. Pragmatism: a guide for the perplexed. L., 2008.
2. Вригт Г. Х. фон. Аналитическая философия: историко-критический обзор / пер. с англ. Л. Б. Макеевой // Кантовский сборник. 2013. Вып. 1 (43). С. 78—89; 2 (44). С. 69—81.
3. Грязнов А. Ф. Феномен аналитической философии в западной культуре ХХ столетия // Вопросы философии. 1996. № 4. С. 37—47.
4. Кант И. Собр. соч.: в 6 т. М., 1965. Т. 4, ч. 1.
5. Макеева Л. Б. Язык, онтология и реализм. М., 2011.
6. Чалый В. А. Питер Стросон об аналитическом, синтетическом и априорном // Рацио.ru: электронный научный журнал. 2010. Вып. 3.
7. Cohen J. L. The dialogue of reason: an analysis of analytical philosophy. Oxford, 1986.
8. Glock H.-J. What is analytic philosophy? Cambridge, 2008.
9. Dummett M. Origins of analytic philosophy. L., 1993.
10. Føllesdal D. Analytic philosophy: what is it and why should one engage in it? // The Rise of Analytic Philosophy / ed. by H.-J. Glock. Oxford, 1997. P. 193—208.
11. Hacker P. The rise of twentieth century analytic philosophy // The Rise of Analytic Philosophy / ed. by H.-J. Glock. Oxford, 1997. P. 51—76.
12. Hanna R. Kant and the foundations of analytic philosophy. Oxford, 2001.
13. Kemp S. N. Commentary to Kant’s “Critique of Pure Reason”. 2nd edn. Atlantic Highlands, 1992.
14. Monk R. What is analytical philosophy? // Bertrand Russell and the origins of analytic philosophy / ed. by R. Monk, A. Palmer. Bristol, 1996. P. 1—23.
15. Idem. Was Russell an Analytic Philosopher? // The Rise of Analytic Philosophy / ed. by H.-J. Glock. Oxford, 1997. P. 35—50.
16. Pap A. Elements of analytical philosophy. N.Y., 1949.
17. Preston A. The implications of recent work in the history of analytic philosophy // Bertrand Russell Society Quarterly. 2005. № 125.
18. Price H. H. Hume’s theory of the external world. Oxford, 1940.
19. Putnam H. Realism with a human face. Cambridge, 1990.
20. Rorty R. Philosophy and the mirror of nature. Princeton, 1979.
21. Ryle G. Taking sides in philosophy // Collected Essays. L., 1971. Vol. 2. P. 153—169.
22. Searle J. Contemporary philosophy in the United States // The Blackwell Companion to Philosophy / ed. N. Bunnin, E. P. Tsui-Lames. Oxford, 1996. P. 1—24.
23. Soames S. Philosophical analysis in the twentieth century. Princeton, 2003. Vol. 1, 2.
24. Story of analytic philosophy: plot and heroes / ed. by A. Biletzki, A. Matar. L., 1998.
25. Stroll A. Twentieth-century analytic philosophy. N.Y., 2000.
26. Talisse R. B., Scott F. A. Pragmatism: a guide for the perplexed. L., 2008.
Reference
1. Bryushinkin, V. N. 2011, Logika Kanta i metafizika Strosona [Kant’s logic and metaphysics Strawson], Kantovsky sbornik, no. 3, p. 7—17.
2. Wright, G. H. von, 2013, Analiticheskaja filosofija: istoriko-kriticheskij obzor [Analytical Philosophy: A Historico-Critical Survey], Kantovsky sbornik, no. 1 (43), p. 78—89; no. 2 (44).
3. Grjaznov, A. F. 1996, Fenomen analiticheskoj filosofii v zapadnoj kul’ture ХХ stoletija [The phenomenon of analytic philosophy in the twentieth century Western culture], Voprosy filosofii [Problems of Philosophy], no. 4, p. 37—47.
4. Kant, I. 1965, Sobranie sochinenij v 6 tomah [Works in 6 volumes], Т. 4, Part. 1, Moscow.
5. Makeeva, L. B. 2011, Jazyk, ontologija i realizm [Language, ontology and realism], Moscow.
6. Chaly, V. A. 2010, Piter Stroson ob analiticheskom, sinteticheskom i apriornom [Peter Strawson on the analytical, synthetic and a priori], Ratio.ru, no. 3.
7. Cohen, J. L. 1986, The dialogue of reason: an analysis of analytical philosophy, Oxford.
8. Glock, H.-J. 2008, What is analytic philosophy? Cambridge.
9. Dummett, M. 1993, Origins of analytic philosophy, London.
10. Føllesdal, D. 1997, Analytic philosophy: what is it and why should one engage in it? In: Glock, H.-J. (ed.) The Rise of Analytic Philosophy, Oxford, p. 193—208.
11. Hacker, P. 1997, The rise of twentieth century analytic philosophy. In: Glock, H.-J. (ed.) The Rise of Analytic Philosophy, Oxford, p. 51—76.
12. Hanna, R. 2001, Kant and the foundations of analytic philosophy, Oxford.
13. Kemp, S. N. 1992, Commentary to Kant’s “Critique of Pure Reason”, Atlantic Highlands.
14. Monk, R. 1996, What is analytical philosophy? In: Monk, R., Palmer, A. (eds.), Bertrand Russell and the origins of analytic philosophy, Bristol, p. 1—23.
15. Monk, R. 1997, Was Russell an Analytic Philosopher? In: Glock, H.-J. (ed.), The Rise of Analytic Philosophy, Oxford, p. 35—50.
16. Pap, A. 1949, Elements of analytical philosophy, N.Y.
17. Preston, A. 2005, The implications of recent work in the history of analytic philosophy, Bertrand Russell Society Quarterly, no. 125.
18. Price, H. H. 1940, Hume’s theory of the external world, Oxford.
19. Putnam, H. 1990, Realism with a human face, Cambridge.
20. Rorty, R. 1979, Philosophy and the mirror of nature, Princeton.
21. Ryle, G. 1971, Taking sides in philosophy. In: Ryle, G. Collected Essays, Vol. 2., London, p. 153—169.
22. Searle, J. 1996, Contemporary philosophy in the United States. In: Bunnin, N., Tsui-Lames, E. P. (eds.), The Blackwell Companion to Philosophy, Oxford, p. 1—24.
23. Soames, S. 2003, Philosophical analysis in the twentieth century, Vol. 1, 2, Princeton.
24. Biletzki, A., Matar, A. (eds.), 1998, Story of analytic philosophy: plot and heroes, London.
25. Stroll, A. 2000, Twentieth-century analytic philosophy, N.Y.
26. Talisse, R. B., Scott, F. A. 2008, Pragmatism: a guide for the perplexed, London.
2. Wright, G. H. von, 2013, Analiticheskaja filosofija: istoriko-kriticheskij obzor [Analytical Philosophy: A Historico-Critical Survey], Kantovsky sbornik, no. 1 (43), p. 78—89; no. 2 (44).
3. Grjaznov, A. F. 1996, Fenomen analiticheskoj filosofii v zapadnoj kul’ture ХХ stoletija [The phenomenon of analytic philosophy in the twentieth century Western culture], Voprosy filosofii [Problems of Philosophy], no. 4, p. 37—47.
4. Kant, I. 1965, Sobranie sochinenij v 6 tomah [Works in 6 volumes], Т. 4, Part. 1, Moscow.
5. Makeeva, L. B. 2011, Jazyk, ontologija i realizm [Language, ontology and realism], Moscow.
6. Chaly, V. A. 2010, Piter Stroson ob analiticheskom, sinteticheskom i apriornom [Peter Strawson on the analytical, synthetic and a priori], Ratio.ru, no. 3.
7. Cohen, J. L. 1986, The dialogue of reason: an analysis of analytical philosophy, Oxford.
8. Glock, H.-J. 2008, What is analytic philosophy? Cambridge.
9. Dummett, M. 1993, Origins of analytic philosophy, London.
10. Føllesdal, D. 1997, Analytic philosophy: what is it and why should one engage in it? In: Glock, H.-J. (ed.) The Rise of Analytic Philosophy, Oxford, p. 193—208.
11. Hacker, P. 1997, The rise of twentieth century analytic philosophy. In: Glock, H.-J. (ed.) The Rise of Analytic Philosophy, Oxford, p. 51—76.
12. Hanna, R. 2001, Kant and the foundations of analytic philosophy, Oxford.
13. Kemp, S. N. 1992, Commentary to Kant’s “Critique of Pure Reason”, Atlantic Highlands.
14. Monk, R. 1996, What is analytical philosophy? In: Monk, R., Palmer, A. (eds.), Bertrand Russell and the origins of analytic philosophy, Bristol, p. 1—23.
15. Monk, R. 1997, Was Russell an Analytic Philosopher? In: Glock, H.-J. (ed.), The Rise of Analytic Philosophy, Oxford, p. 35—50.
16. Pap, A. 1949, Elements of analytical philosophy, N.Y.
17. Preston, A. 2005, The implications of recent work in the history of analytic philosophy, Bertrand Russell Society Quarterly, no. 125.
18. Price, H. H. 1940, Hume’s theory of the external world, Oxford.
19. Putnam, H. 1990, Realism with a human face, Cambridge.
20. Rorty, R. 1979, Philosophy and the mirror of nature, Princeton.
21. Ryle, G. 1971, Taking sides in philosophy. In: Ryle, G. Collected Essays, Vol. 2., London, p. 153—169.
22. Searle, J. 1996, Contemporary philosophy in the United States. In: Bunnin, N., Tsui-Lames, E. P. (eds.), The Blackwell Companion to Philosophy, Oxford, p. 1—24.
23. Soames, S. 2003, Philosophical analysis in the twentieth century, Vol. 1, 2, Princeton.
24. Biletzki, A., Matar, A. (eds.), 1998, Story of analytic philosophy: plot and heroes, London.
25. Stroll, A. 2000, Twentieth-century analytic philosophy, N.Y.
26. Talisse, R. B., Scott, F. A. 2008, Pragmatism: a guide for the perplexed, London.