Kant’s lectures on natural law: Justice and conscientiousness
- DOI
- 10.5922/0207-6918-2016-4-5
- Pages
- 63-72
Abstract
The lectures on natural law delivered by Kant in the winter semester of 1784/85 have recently attracted increasing attention from Kant scholars. Dating back to the 1780s, they elucidate a number of important aspects in the genesis of Kant’s practical philosophy. Firstly, this relates to the formation of the Königsberg philosopher’s views on law. However, the lecture notes (especially the introduction) are of equal importance to understanding certain problems of Kant’s ethical concept and interpretation of the connection between ethics and law. An important role is played by the concept of Billigkeit, which is rather difficult to translate into the Russian language and is found in other Kant’s texts on practical philosophy. This term is usually translated as justice. However, there is another word in the German language — Gerechtihkeit — that has the meaning of justice. Moreover, such translation of Billigkeit creates a false connection with the realm of law, which Kant tried to avoid stressing the difference between Billigkeit and Gerechtigkeit. If Gerechtigkeit relates to external deeds subject to legal regulation and external enforcement, Billigkeit relates to tacit intentions and dispositions that cannot be controlled from the outside. This supports the thesis about the difference between ethics and law and the need for a more accurate identification of the place of natural law in the system of practical philosophy.
Reference
1. Davydova, L., S. 1996, Immanuil Kant. Bibliograficheskij ukazatel literatury na russkom jazykie 1803—1994 gg. [Immanuel Kant. Bibliographic index of literature in Russian 1803—1994], Moscow.
2. Hinski, N. 2014, Nezamechennyj kommentarij Kanta 1784 goda k “Osnovopolozheniju k metafiziki nravov” (1785) [An Annoticed Kant’s Commentary to the “Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals” (1785) from 1784], Istoriki-filosofskij jezhegodnik [History of Philosophy Yearbook], p. 31—38.
3. Kant, I. 1994, Metafizika nravov [Metaphysic of Morals], in: Sobr. soch. w 8 tomach, ed. by A. V. Gulyga, Moscow, T. 6.
4. Kant, I. 1997, Kritika prakticheskogo razuma [Critique of practical reason], in: Sochinenija v 4-ch tt. na russkom i nemeckom jazyke [Works in 4 vol. in Russian and German], ed. by N. V. Motroshilova, B. Tushling. Moscow, Vol. 3.
5. Kant, I. 2014, Metafizika nravov [Metaphysic of Morals], in: Sochinenija v 4-ch tt. na russkom i nemeckom jazyke [Works in 4 vol. in Russian and German], ed. by N. V. Motroshilova, B. Tushling. Moscow, Vol. 3.
6. Kant, I. 2016a, Jestestvennoje pravo Fajerabjenda. Vvedenije [Natural Law of Feyerabend. Introduction], Kantovskij sbornik [Kant review], no. 3, p. 75—81.
7. Kant, I. 2016b, Jestestvennoje pravo Fajerabjenda. Vvedenije (okonchanie) [Natural Law of Feyerabend. Introduction (the end)], Kantovskij sbornik [Kant review], no. 4, p. 58—62.
8. Kant, I. 2016с, Lekzii o filosofskom uchenii o religii [Lectures on philosophical doctrine of religion], transl. by L. E. Kryshtop, Moscow.
9. Moskalskij, O., I. (ed.) 2001, Bolshoj niemecko-russkij slovar: v 3-ch tt. [German-Russian Dictionary], Moscow, Vol. 1. Т. 1.
10. Brandt, R. 1982, Das Erlaubnisgesetz, oder: Vernunft und Geschichte in Kants Rechtslehre, Rechtsphilosophie der Aufklärung. Symposium Wolfenbüttel, hrsg. von R. Brandt, Berlin, S. 233—285.
11. Delfosse, H. P., Hinske, N., Sadun Bordoni, G. 2010—2014, Kant-Index, Bd. 30, Stellenindex und Konkordanz zum „Naturrecht Feyerabend“, Tl. 1, Einleitung des „Naturrechts Feyerabend“, Stuttgart-Bad Cannstatt.
12. Guyer, P. 2012, Stellenindex und Konkordanz zum Naturrecht Feyerabend, Teilband I: Einleitung des Naturrechts Feyerabend, Ratio Juris, Vol. 25, p. 110—116.
13. Hirsch, Ph.-A. 2012, Kants Einleitung in die Rechtslehre von 1784. Immanuel Kants Rechtsbegriff in der Moralvorlesung „Mrongovius II“ und der Naturrechtsvorlesung „Feyerabend“ von 1784 sowie in der „Metaphysik der Sitten“ von 1797, Göttingen.
14. Kant, I. 1937, Vorlesungen über die philosophische Religionslehre, hrsg. von K. Beyer, Halle.
15. Kant, I. 1978, Lectures on Philosophical Religion, transl. by A. W. Wood, G. M. Clark, Ithaca, London.
16. Kant, I. 1998a, Kritik der praktischen Vernunft, in: Werke in sechs Bänden, hrsg. von W. Weischedel. Darmstadt, Bd. IV.
17. Kant, I. 1998b, Die Metaphysik der Sitten, in: Werke in sechs Bänden, hrsg. von W. Weischedel, Darmstadt, Bd. IV.
18. Kant, I. 2000, Lecciones sobre la filosofía de la religion, ed. por A. del Río, E. Romerales, Madrid, p. 137.
19. Kant, I. 2016d, Lezioni sul Diritto Naturale (Naturrecht Feyerabend). Testo tedesco a fronte, a cura di N. Hinske, G. Sadun Bordoni, Milano.
20. Sadun Bordoni, G., 2016 a, Introduzione, Kant I. Lezioni sul Diritto Naturale (Naturrecht Feyerabend), a cura di N. Hinske, G. Sadun Bordoni. Milano, p. 9—50.