Search
Submit an article RU
Kantian Journal

Current issue

Back to the list Download the article
ENG
Сохранить XML для: JATS (вып.)
RUS
Сохранить XML для: JATS (вып.)
Babich B.

Kant’s Philosophy of Chemistry and Nietzsche’s Cosmology. Part II: Chemistry as a Science, the Alchemy of Economics, and Spiritual Gold

DOI
10.5922/0207-6918-2026-2-5
Pages
93-131
Kant Nietzsche the nature of science mathematics in chemistry economic alchemy spiritual alchemy hermeneutic history philosophy of science

Abstract

Continuing from Part One (see “Kantian Journal”, vol. 44, no. 3), this article reviews Kant’s dismissal of chemistry as a ‘proper’ science in light of his specific examples (instancing Stahl’s spagyric experiments, cinnabar, and gold) to argue that understanding Kant requires an historical hermeneutical approach to science. Close textual analysis of Kant’s writings is compared with an historically-informed reading of early modern chemistry and alchemy, which looks at Stahl, Boyle, Paneth, discussions by historians and philosophers of science, Goethe (in connection with his business enterprise), and, on a theological level, Reiner Schürmann, among others. A “material hermeneutics” of exemplary substances — cinnabar, in particular — in addition to Kant’s use of chemical examples, can illustrate gradations in science, the distinction between analysis and synthesis, and the conditions for possible experience, as well as the later reception of these themes in the philosophy of chemistry and the history of alchemy. The main findings show, first, that Kant’s treatment of chemistry is more complex than a simple exclusion from “proper science” suggests. Secondly, Kant’s example of cinnabar “now red, now black,” presupposes empirical instability. Lastly, the article argues that the continued marginalisation of alchemy in historical writing perpetuates a Whiggish scientistic bias, and that a hermeneutic approach can reveal deeper continuities between alchemy, chemistry, and Kant’s critical philosophy.

Full text

json#{"TEXT":"","TYPE":"HTML"}

Reference

Agassi, J., 1971. Kant’s Program. Synthese, 23(1), pp. 18-23.

Alleau, R., 1977. La science des symbols. Contribution à l’étude des principes et des méthodes de la symbolique Générale. Paris: Payot.

Andreae, J. V., 2001. Chymische Hochzeit des Christiani Rosencreutz Anno 1459. Edited by B. Baan. Stuttgart: Urachhaus.

Angelus Silesius (Scheffler J.), 2000. Cherubinischer Wandersmann. Kritische Ausgabe. Edited by L. Gnädinger. Stuttgart: Reclam.

Babich, B., 2004. Nietzsche’s göttliche Eidechse: ‘Divine Lizards’, ‘Greene Lyons’ and Music. In: R. and C. Davis Acampora, eds., 2004. Nietzsche’s Bestiary. Lanham: Rowman & Littlefield, pp. 264-283.

Babich, B., 2010. Towards a Critical Philosophy of Science: Continental Beginnings and Bugbears, Whigs, and Waterbears. International Studies in the Philosophy of Science, 24(4), pp. 343-391.

Babich, B., 2013. Early Continental Philosophy of Science. In: K. Ansell-Pearson, A. D. Schrift, eds., 2013. The History of Continental Philosophy, Volume 3. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, pp. 264-286.

Babich, B., 2018. Heidegger and Hölderlin on Aether and Life. Études Phénoménologique, Phenomenological Studies, 2, pp. 111-133.

Babich, B., 2021. Die ewige Sanduhr des Daseins. In: Nietzsches Plastik. Ästhetische Phänomenologie im Spiegel des Lebens. Oxford & Berlin & Bern: Peter Lang, pp. 385-416.

Babich, B., 2025. Kant’s Philosophy of Chemistry and Nietzsche’s Cosmology: On the Material Hermeneutics of Alchemy and Cinnabar. Part I. Kantian Journal, 44(3), pp. 43-80. https://dx.doi.org/10.5922/0207-6918-2025-3-2.

Bensaude-Vincent, B., 2009. A Historical Perspective on Science and Its ‘Others’. Isis, 100(2), pp. 359-368.

Berg, H. van den, 2011. Kant’s Conception of Proper Science. Synthese, 183(1), pp. 7-26.

Binswanger, H. C., 1994. Money and Magic: A Critique of the Modern Economy in the Light of Goethe’s Faust. Translated by J. E. Harrison. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Bloch, R., 1952. Goethe, Idealistic Morphology, and Science. American Scientist, 40(2), pp. 313-322.

Blomme, H., 2015. Kant’s Conception of Chemistry in the Danziger Physik. In: R. R. Clewis, ed., 2015. Reading Kant’s Lectures. Berlin: de Gruyter, pp. 484-502.

Brakel, J. van, 2006. Kant’s Legacy for the Philosophy of Chemistry. In: E. Scerri, D. Baird and L. McIntyre, eds. 2006. Philosophy of Chemistry. Frankfurt: Springer, pp. 69-91.

Brock, W. H., 2000. The Chemical Tree: A History of Chemistry. New York: W.W. Norton and Company.

Buchdahl, G., 1992. Kant and the Dynamics of Reason. Oxford: Blackwell.

Buzzoni, M., 2018a. Kantian Accounts of Thought Experiments. In: M. T. Stuart, Y. Fehige and J. R. Brown, eds. 2018. The Routledge Companion to Thought Experiments. London: Routledge, pp. 327-341.

Buzzoni, M., 2018b. Pierre Duhem and Ernst Mach on Thought Experiments. HOPOS: The Journal of the International Society for the History of Philosophy of Science, 8(1), pp. 1-27.

Carrier, M., 2000. Kant’s Theory of Matter and his Views on Chemistry. In: E. Watkins, ed. 2000. Kant and the Sciences. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 205-230.

Carus, P. G., 1908. Angelus Silesius. The Open Court, 5, Art. 4, pp. 291-296.

Cassirer, E., 1922. Einstein’s Theory of Relativity Considered from the Epistemological Standpoint. The Monist, 32(2), pp. 248-303.

Caygill, H., 1989. The Art of Judgment. Oxford: Basil Blackwell.

Coudert, A., 1980. Alchemy: The Philosopher’s Stone. London: Wildwood House, 1980.

Davidson, R. S. and Willsher, C.J., 1981. The Light-Induced Blackening of the Red Mercury (II) Sulfide. Journal of the Chemical Society, 3, pp. 833-835.

Davis, T. L., 1936. The Problem of the Origins of Alchemy. The Scientific Monthly, 43(6), pp. 551-558.

Debus, A. G., 1967. Fire Analysis and the Elements in the Sixteenth and Seventeenth Centuries. Annals of Science, XXIII, pp. 127-147.

Desiraju, G. R., 2005. Chemistry — The Middle Kingdom. Current Science, 88(3), pp. 374-380.

Dobbs, B. J. T., 1975. The Foundations of Newton’s Alchemy: or, “The Hunting of the Greene Lyon”. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Dobbs, B. J. T. and Jacob, M. C., 1998. Newton and the Culture of Newtonianism. Amherst, NY: Humanity Books.

Drake, S., 1975. The Role of Music in Galileo’s Experiments. Scientific American, 232(6), pp. 98-105.

Eliade, M., 1978. The Forge and the Crucible: The Origins and Structures of Alchemy. Translated by S. Corrin. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Falque, E., 2018. Hors phénomène. Revue de Métaphysique et de Morale, 99(3), pp. 323-344. https://doi.org/10.3917/rmm.183.0323.

Falque, E., 2022. Cinabre : aux limites des analogies de l’expérience. Transversalités, 162, pp. 173-192.

Friedman, M., 1992. Kant and the Exact Sciences. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

Gibney, E., 2025. Physicists Turn Lead into Gold — For a Fraction of a Second. Nature. 05/09. https://doi.org/10.1038/d41586-025-01484-3

Goetschl, W., 1994. Constituting Critique: Kant’s Writing as Critical Practice. Durham: Duke University Press.

Goltz, D., 1972. „Alchemie und Aufklärung: Ein Beitrag zur Naturwissenschafts-geschichtsschreibung der Aufklärung.“ Medizinhistorisches Journal, 7(1-2), pp. 31-48.

Gray, R. D., 2010. Goethe the Alchemist: A Study of Alchemical Symbolism in Goethe’s Literary and Scientific Works. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Hale, T., 2025. Gold Can Be Made by Scientists in a Lab — There’s Just One Problem. All you need is a nuclear reaction, a particle accelerator, or the blast of a supernova. IFL Science. 9 July. URL: https://www.iflscience.com/gold-can-be-made-by-scientists-in-a-lab-theres-just-one-problem-79944 (accessed on 4.12.2025)

Heisenberg, W., 1958. The Physicist’s Conception of Nature. Translated by A. Pomerans. London: Hutchinson Scientific and Technical.

Hoffmann, R., 2007. What Might Philosophy of Science Look like If Chemists Built It? Synthese, 115(3), Topics in the Philosophy of Chemistry, pp. 321-336.

Hooykaas, R., 1949. The Experimental Origin of Chemical Atomic and Molecular Theory before Boyle. Chymia, 2, pp. 65-80.

Hyde, S. T., 1998. Boxing Partula. Forma, 13, pp. 145-178.

Hyde, S. T., 2023. Boxing Partula: 25 Years After. Substantia, 7(1), pp. 45-65.

Kahn, D., 2016. Le Fixe et le Volatil. Chimie et alchimie, de Paracelse à Lavoisier. Paris: CNRS Editions.

Kahn, D. and Newman, W.R., 2025. Spagyria, Scheidung, and Spagürlein: The Meanings of Analysis for Paracelsus. In: N. and J. Schickore, eds. 2025. Traditions of Analysis and Synthesis. Cham: Springer, pp. 41-58.

Kant, I., 1891. Metaphysical Foundations of Science. Translated by E. B. Bax. London: Bell and Sons.

Kant, I. 1993. Opus Postumum. Translated by E. Förster and M. Rosen. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Kant, I., 1996. Toward Perpetual Peace. A Philosophical Project (1795). In: I. Kant, 1996. Practical philosophy. Translated and edited by M. J. Gregor. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 317-351.

Kant, I., 1998. Critique of Pure Reason. Translated and edited by P. Guyer and A. Wood. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Kant, I., 2004. Prolegomena to any Future Metaphysics. Translated by G. Hatfield. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Kerschagl, R., 1973. Die Jagd nach dem künstlichen Gold. Der Weg der Alchimie. Berlin: Duncker & Humblott.

Klein, J. A. and Ragland, E., 2014. Introduction. Analysis and Synthesis in Medieval and Early Modern Europe. Ambix, 61(4), pp. 319-326. https://doi.org/10.1179/0002698014Z.00000000065.

Klein, J. T., 2021. On Serpents and Doves: The Systematic Relationship between Prudence and Morality in Kant’s Political Philosophy. Kant-Studien, 112(1), pp. 78-104. https://doi.org/10.1515/kant-2021-0003.

Lemanski, J., 2016. Galilei, Torricelli, Stahl. Zur Wissenschaftsgeschichte der Physik in der B-Vorrede zu Kants Kritik der reinen Vernunft. Kant-Studien, 107(3), pp. 451-484. https://doi.org/10.1515/kant-2016-0034.

Lindberg, I. M., 2023. The Revival of Alchemy: The Cumulative Creation of a Tradition. In: A. Vestrucci, ed. 2023. Beyond Babel: Religion and Linguistic Pluralism. Springer, pp. 227-243.

Love, R., 1972. Some Sources of Hermann Boerhaave’s Concept of Fire. Ambix, 19(3), pp. 157-174.

Mahootian, F., 2020. Kant, Cassirer, and the Idea of Chemical Element. In: E. Scerri and E. Ghibaudi, eds., What Is a Chemical Element? A Collection of Essays by Chemists, Philosophers, Historians, and Educators, Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 143-166.

MacIntyre, A., 1980. After Virtue. Notre Dame: Notre Dame University Press.

MacIntyre, L., 2007. The Philosophy of Chemistry: Ten Years Later. Synthese, 155(3), pp. 291-292.

Malabou, C., 2014. Can We Relinquish the Transcendental? The Journal of Speculative Philosophy, 28(3), pp. 242-255. https://doi.org/10.5325/jspecphil.28.3.0242.

Martindale, C., 2004. Latin Poetry and the Judgement of Taste: An Essay in Aesthetics. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Mather, M., 2014. The Alchemical Mercurius. New York: Routledge.

Matson, J., 2014. Fact or Fiction? Lead Can Be Turned into Gold. Particle accelerators make possible the ancient alchemist’s dream — but at a steep cost. Scientific American. 31 January 2014. URL: https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/fact-or-fiction-lead-can-be-turned-into-gold/ (accessed on 04.11.2021).

Mendus, S., 1988. The Serpent and the Dove. Philosophy, 63(245), pp. 331-343.

Metzger, H., 1930. Newton, Stahl, Boerhaave et la doctrine chimique. Paris: F. Alcan.

Mirowski, P., 1987. The Philosophical Bases of Institutionalist Economics. Journal of Economic Issues. Evolutionary Economics I: Foundations of Institutional Thought. 21(3), pp. 1001-1038.

Mirowski, P., 1991. More Heat than Light: Economics as Social Physics, Physics as Nature’s Economics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Mirowski, P., 2004. The Effortless Economy of Science. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.

Mohanty, J.N., 1996. Kant and Husserl. Husserl Studies, 13(1), pp. 19-30.

Montgomery, J.W. 1973. Cross and Crucible: Johann Valentin Andreae (1586-1654): Phoenix of the Theologians, Volume 1: Andreae’s Life, Worldview, and Relations with Rosicrucianism and Alchemy. The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff.

Müller, O., 2018. Goethe’s Polarity of Light and Darkness. Journal for General Philosophy of Science / Zeitschrift für Allgemeine Wissenschaftstheorie, 49(4), pp. 581-598.

Newman, W. R. and Principe L. M., 2002. Alchemy Tried in the Fire: Starkey, Boyle, and the Fate of Helmontian Chymistry. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Nietzsche, F., 1967. The Birth of Tragedy and the Case of Wagner. Translated by W. Kaufmann. New York: Random House, pp. 1-144.

Nietzsche, F., 1980a. Also sprach Zarathustra. In: F. Nietzsche, 1980. Sämtliche Werke. Edited by G. Colli and M. Montinari. Volume 4: Also sprach Zarathustra I-IV. Berlin & New York: Walter de Gruyter.

Nietzsche, F., 1980b. Die Geburt der Tragödie aus dem Geiste der Musik. In: F. Nietzsche, 1980. Sämtliche Werke. Edited by G. Colli and M. Montinari. Volume 1: Die Geburt der Tragödie, Unzeitgemäße Betrachtungen I—IV, Nachgelassene Schriften 1870—1873. Berlin: de Gruyter, pp. 9-156.

Nietzsche, F., 1980c. Die dionysische Weltanschauung. In: F. Nietzsche, 1980. Sämtliche Werke. Edited by G. Colli and M. Montinari. Volume 1. Berlin & New York: Walter de Gruyter, pp. 551-577.

Nietzsche, F., 1980d. Die Geburt des tragischen Gedankens. In: F. Nietzsche, 1980. Sämtliche Werke. Edited by G. Colli and M. Montinari. Volume 1. Berlin & New York: Walter de Gruyter, pp. 579-599.

Nietzsche, F., 1980e. Nachgelassene Fragmente 1869—1874. Teil 7 = U I 2b. Ende 1870 — April 1871. In: F. Nietzsche, 1980. Sämtliche Werke. Edited by G. Colli, M. Montinari. Volume 7: Nachgelassene Fragmente 1869—1874. Berlin & New York: Walter de Gruyter, pp. 9-838.

Nietzsche, F., 1980f. Nachgelassene Fragmente 1885—1887. Teil 9 W II 1. Herbst 1887. In: F. Nietzsche, 1980. Sämtliche Werke. Edited by G. Colli and M. Montinari. Volume 12: Nachgelassene Fragmente 1885-1887. Berlin & New York: Walter de Gruyter, pp. 339-451.

Ninham, B. W., 2017. The Biological/Physical Sciences Divide, and the Age of Unreason. Substantia. An International Journal of the History of Chemistry, 1(1), pp. 7-24.

Paneth, F. A., 1962. The Epistemological Status of the Chemical Concept of Element (I). The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science, 13(49), pp. 1-14.

Parshall, K. H., 2015. Crafting the Chemical Interpretation of Nature: The Work of Allen G. Debus. In: K. H. Parshall, M. T. Walton and B. T. Moran, eds. 2016. Bridging Traditions: Alchemy, Chemistry, and Paracelsian Practices in the Early Modern Era. State College: Penn State University Press, pp. 1-18.

Partington, J. P., 1948. The Concepts of Substance and Chemical Element. Chymia, 1, pp. 109-121.

Pfau, T. 2010. ‘All is Leaf’: Difference, Metamorphosis, and Goethe’s Phenomenology of Knowledge. Studies in Romanticism, 49(1), pp. 3-41.

Pliny, 1952. Natural History. Volume IX: Books 33-35. Translated by H. Rackham. Cambridge: Loeb Library.

Principe, L., 1998. The Aspiring Adept: Robert Boyle and His Alchemical Quest. Princeton: Princeton University Press.

Principe, L., 2014. The End of Alchemy? The Repudiation and Persistence of Chrysopoeia at the Académie Royale des Sciences in the Eighteenth Century. Osiris, 29(1), Chemical Knowledge in the Early Modern World: pp. 96-116.

Ramsay, J., 1997. Alchemy: The Art of Transfiguration. San Francisco: Thorsens [Harper & Row].

Roberts, A., 2019. Framing a Middle Byzantine Alchemical Codex. Dumbarton Oaks Papers, 73, pp. 69-102.

Robinson, D. S., 1950. Kant and Demonax — A Footnote to the History of Philosophy. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research, 10(3), pp. 374-379.

Rola, S. K. de., 1988. The Golden Game: Alchemical Engravings of the Seventeenth Century. With 533 illustrations. London: Thames and Hudson.

Schaffer, S., 1978. The Phoenix of Nature: Fire and Evolutionary Cosmology in Wright and Kant. Journal for the History of Astronomy, IX, pp. 180-200.

Schmid, H., 1984. Nietzsches Gedanke der tragischen Erkenntnis. Würzburg: Königshausen & Neumann.

Schopenhauer, A., 2007. Über die Grundlagen der Moral. Hamburg: Felix Meiner.

Schrödinger, E., 1944. What is Life? Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Schürmann, R., 2003. Broken Hegemonies. Translated by Reginald Lilly. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.

Schummer, J., 1997. Towards a Philosophy of Chemistry. Journal for General Philosophy of Science / Zeitschrift für allgemeine Wissenschaftstheorie, 28(2), pp. 307-336.

Schummer, J., 2012. Why Mathematical Chemistry Cannot Copy Mathematical Physics and How to Avoid the Imminent Epistemological Pitfalls. HYLE — International Journal for Philosophy of Chemistry, 18(1), pp. 71-89.

Seifert, V., 2024. There is More to Alchemy Than Its Mystical Nature. Chemistry World, Royal Society of Chemistry. Available at: https://www.chemistryworld.com/opinion/theres-more-to-alchemy-than-its-mystical-nature/4019675.artic... (accessed on 7.12.2024).

Smith, P. H., 1994. The Business of Alchemy: Science and Culture in the Holy Roman Empire. Princeton: Princeton University Press.

Stahl, G. E., 1731. Materia medica: das ist: Zubereitung, Krafft und Würckung, derer sonderlich durch chymische Kunst erfundenen Artzneyen. Dresden: Zimmermann und Gerlach.

Strong, T. B., 1975. Friedrich Nietzsche and the Politics of Transfiguration. Berkeley: University of California Press.

Terrapon, V., Béarat, H., 2010. A Study of Cinnabar Blackening: New Approach and Treatment Perspective. The 7th International Conference on Science and Technology in Archaeology and Conservation. At: Petra, Jordan. URL: https://staff.najah.edu/media/sites/default/files/A_Study_of_Cinnabar_Blackening_New_Approach_and_Tr... (accessed on 22.09.2020)

Tilton, H., 2007. Of Ether and Colloidal Gold: The Making of a Philosophers’ Stone. Esoterica, IX, pp. 49-128.

Trinquier, J., 2013. Cinnabaris and Dragon’s Blood: Ancient ‘Cinnabar’ between Mineral, Plant, and Animal. Revue archéologique. 56(2), pp. 305-346.

Valentine, B., 1678. His Triumphant Chariot of Antimony with Annotations of Theodore Kirkringus, M.D. With: The True Book of the learned Synesius, a Greek Abbot taken out the Emperor’s Library, concerning the Philosopher’s Stone. London: Printed for Dorman Newman at the Kings Arms in the Poultry.

Waples, J. S., Nagy K. L., Aiken G. R. and Ryan J. N., 2005. Dissolution of cinnabar (HgS) in the Presence of Natural Organic Matter. Geochimica et Cosmochimiсa Acta, 69(6), pp. 1575-1588.

Wennerlind, C., 2003. Credit-Money as the Philosopher’s Stone: Alchemy and the Coinage Problem in Seventeenth-Century England. History of Political Economy, 35(5), pp. 234-261.

Wentrup, C., 2024. Johann Rudolph Glauber: The Royals’ Alchemist and his Secret Recipes. Found Chem, 26, pp. 3-13.

Wentrup, C., 2025. The Gold-Maker of Animal Oil and Prussian Blue Fame — The Chemical and Medicinal Science Philosophy of Johann Conrad Dippel. The Chemical Record, 25, pp. 1-39.

Werner, R. A., 2018. Princes of the Yen, Japan’s Central Bankers and the Transformation of the Economy. Armonk, N. Y.: M. E. Sharpe.

Westphal, K. R., 1997. Affinity, Idealism and Naturalism: The Stability of Cinnabar and the Possibility of Experience. Kant-Studien, 88, pp. 139-189.