Search
Submit an article RU
Kantian Journal

2023 Vol. 42. №1

Back to the list Download the article
ENG
Сохранить XML для: JATS (вып.)
RUS
Сохранить XML для: JATS (вып.)
Antonov K.M.

From Kant to Frank: The Ethic of Duty and the Problem of Resistance to Evil in Russian Thought

DOI
10.5922/0207-6918-2023-1-2
Pages
10-51
Kant Tolstoy Frank ethic of duty categorical imperative ethic of salvation resistance to evil nonresistance principle of the lesser evil

Abstract

One of the key ethical debates in Russian religious thought, initiated by Leo Tolstoy, concerned the question of nonresistance to evil by force. The purpose of this article is to assess the influence of Kant’s ethics and philosophy of religion on the course of this debate and to determine the place and significance of the arguments and considerations expressed on this issue by Semyon Frank in the early and late periods (1908 and 1940s) of his work. To this end I reconstruct the general course of the debate, notably the positions and arguments of Leo Tolstoy, Vladimir Solovyov, Ivan Ilyin and Nikolai Berdyaev. Beginning with Tolstoy, Russ­ian thinkers introduced the original ethical content of the idea of nonresistance derived from the Gospel into the ethics of duty borrowed from Kant. The Tolstoy version of this idea was challenged mainly from two directions: from the Kantian grounding of the legitimacy of coercion and attempts to bring in styles of moral thinking other than the ethic of duty. Ilyin’s apolo­gia for the use of force in the struggle against evil prompted Russian émigré thinkers to take a closer look at Tolstoy’s ethical concept and pay attention to its positive content. On this basis Berdyaev and especially Frank create their version of the Christ-centered ethic of salvation which, in the perspective of “protecting the world against evil” includes the ethic of duty and links it with the possibility of using force, always a wrongful act, but one justified “in a situation of extreme need”.

Reference

Aljaev, G. E., Obolevich, T. and Rezvykh, T.N., 2021. “Svet vo t’me” i “S nami Bog”: neizvestnye knigi S. L. Franka [The Light Shineth in the Darkness and God with Us: The Unknown Books of S. L. Frank]. Moscow: Modest Kolerov. (In Rus.)

Berdyaev, N. A., 1912. The Old and New Testament in L. Tolstoy’s Religious Consciousness. In: Sbornik vtoroi. O religii L’va Tolstogo [The Second Collection. On Lev Tolstoy’s Religion], 1912. Moscow: Put’, pp. 172-195. (In Rus.)

Berdyaev, N., 2015. The Philosophy of Inequality. Letters to my Contemners, Concerning Social Philosophy. In: N. Berdyaev, 2015. The Philosophy of Inequality. Letters to my Contemners, Concerning Social Philosophy (1923); Spirits of the Russian Revolution: Gogol, Dostoevsky, L. Tolstoy (1918). Translated by Fr. S. Janos. Mohrsville, PA: frsj Publications, pp. 1-291.

Berdyaev, N. A., 1926. A Nightmare of Evil Good. Put’ [The Way], 4, pp. 103-116. (In Rus.)

Berdyaev, N. A., 1993. The Destiny of Man. Reprint of the 4th edition published by G. Bles. Westport, Connecticut: Hyperion Press.

Chernov, V. S., 2004. Peace, Sword and World. In: I. I. Evlampiev, ed. 2004. I. A. Il’in: pro et contra. Lichnost’ i tvorchestvo Ivana Il’ina v vospominaniyakh, dokumentakh i ocenkakh russkikh myslitelei i issledovatelei: antologiya [I.A. Ilyin: Pro et Contra. Ivan Ilyin’s Person and Work in Memoirs, Documents and Assessments of Russian Thinkers and Researchers: An Anthology]. St. Petersburg: Izdatel’stvo Russkogo Hristianskogo gumanitarnogo instituta, pp. 617-640. (In Rus.)

Frank, S. L., 1946. God with Us. Three Meditations. Translated by N. Duddington. New Haven: Yale University Press.

Frank, S. L., 1989. The Light Shineth in the Darkness: An Essay in Christian Ethics and Social Philosophy. Translated by B. Jakim. Athens: Ohio University Press.

Frank, S. L., 2020a. The Moral Teaching of Tolstoy. In: S. L. Frank, 2020. Polnoe sobranie sochinenii [Complete Works]. Volume 3: 1908—1910. Moscow: PSTGU, pp. 57-66. (In Rus.)

Frank, S. L., 2020b. Lev Tolstoy and Russian intelligencija. In: S. L. Frank, 2020. Polnoe sobranie sochinenii [Complete Works]. Volume 3: 1908—1910. Moscow: PSTGU, pp. 67-73. (In Rus.)

Evlampiev, I. I., 1998. Bozhestvennoe i chelovecheskoe v filosofii Ivana Il’ina [Divine and Human in the Philosophy of Ivan Ilyin]. St. Petersburg: Nauka. (In Rus.)

Evlampiev, I. I., ed. 2004. I. A. Il’in: pro et contra. Lichnost’ i tvorchestvo Ivana Il’ina v vospominaniyakh, dokumentakh i ocenkakh russkikh myslitelei i issledovatelei: antologiya [I. A. Ilyin: Pro et Contra. Ivan Ilyin’s Person and Work in Memoirs, Documents and Assessments of Russian Thinkers and Researchers: An Anthology]. St. Petersburg: Izdatel’stvo Russkogo Hristianskogo gumanitarnogo instituta. (In Rus.)

Gelfond, M. L., 2008. Critique of Tolstoy’s Doctrine of Non-Resistance to Evil by Violence in Russian Religious-Philosophical Thought in the Late 19th and Early 20th Centuries: Three Main Arguments. In: Theoretical Workshop of the Division of Ethics of the Institute of Philosophy RAS, Moscow. Available at: https://iphras.ru/uplfile/ethics/seminar/gelfond_q.html (accessed 15 November 2022). (In Rus.)

Guseinov, A. A., 2014. Non-resistance to Evil by Force. In: A. A. Gusejnov and T. G. Shchedrina, eds. 2014. Lev Nikolaevich Tolstoy. Moscow: ROSSPEN, pp. 219-247. (In Rus.)

Gusejnov, A. A. and Shchedrina, T. G., 2014. From Editors. In: A. A. Gusejnov and T. G. Shchedrina, eds. 2014. Lev Nikolaevich Tolstoy. Moscow: ROSSPEN, pp. 5-8. (In Rus.)

Ilyin, I. A., 1914. The Main Moral Contradiction of War. Voprosy filosofii i psihologii [The Issues of Philosophy and Psychology], 125(5), pp. 797-826. (In Rus.)

Ilyin, I.A., 2018. On Resistance to Evil by Force. Translated by K. Benois. Zvolen & London: Taxiarch Press.

Kant, I.,1996a. An Answer to the Question: What is Enlightenment? In: I. Kant, 1996. Practical Philosophy. Edited by M. Gregor. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 15-22.

Kant, I., 1996b. The Metaphysics of Morals. In: I. Kant, 1996. Practical Philosophy. Edited by M. Gregor, General Introduction by A. Wood. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 365-603.

Kant, I., 1997. Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals. Translated and edited by M. Gregor. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Kant, I., 2009. Religion within the Bounds of Bare Reason. Translated by W. S. Pluhar, Introduction by S. R. Palmquist. Indianapolis: Hackett.

Kant, I., 2015. Critique of Practical Reason. Translated and edited by M. Gregor, with a revised introduction by A. Reath. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Kolerov, M. A., 1996. Ne mir, no mech. Russkaja religiozno-filosofskaja pechat’ ot “Problem idealizma” do “Vekh” [Not the Peace, but the Sword. The Russian Religious-Philosophical Press from The Problems of Idealism to the Signposts], 1902—1909. St. Petersburg: Aleteya. (In Rus.)

Krouglov, A. N., 2012a. Kant i kantovskaya filosofiya v russkoi khudozhestvennoi literature [Kant and Kantian Philosophy in Russian Fiction]. Moscow: «Kanon+». (In Rus.)

Krouglov, A. N., 2012b. Law in the Perception of the Late Tolstoy. In: Lev Tolstoj i mirovaja literatura: materialy VII Mezhdunarodnoi nauchnoi konferentsii [Lev Tolstoy and World Literature: Proceedings of the 7th International Conference] (Yasnaya Polyana, 10-15 August 2010), 2012. Tula: “Yasnaya Polyana”, pp. 267-283. (In Rus.)

Krouglov, A. N., 2021. The Polemic on “Amorphism” in Ethics: The Late V. S. Solovyov vs L. N. Tolstoy. In: Lev Tolstoj i mirovaya literatura: materialy XI Mezhdu­narodnoi nauchnoi konferentsii [Lev Tolstoy and World Literature: Proceedings of the 11th International Conference] (Yasnaya Polyana, 11-15 August 2018), 2021. Tula: “Yasnaja Polyana”, pp. 203-218. (In Rus.)

Lisitsa, Yu. N., ed. 2007. I. A. Ilyin: O soprotivlenii zlu siloju; Pro et contra: Polemika vokrug idej I. A. Il’ina o soprotivlenii zlu siloju [I. A. Ilyin: On Resistance to Evil by Force; Pro et contra. The Polemic Around I. A. Ilyin’s Ideas on Resistance to Evil by Force]. Moscow: Airis-Press. (In Rus.)

Losev, A. F., 2009. Vl. Solov’ev i ego vremya [Vl. Solovyov and His Time]. Moscow: Molodaya gvardiya. (In Rus.)

Nizhnikov, S. A., 2013. Shall We Resist Evil by Force? The Problem of Morals in Philosophy-Political Discourse. Space and Time: E-Almanac, 3(2). Available at: http://www.j-spacetime.com/actual%20content/t3v2/3221.php (accessed 30 June 2022). (In Rus.)

Orekhanov, G., 2016. Lev Tolstoi. “Prorok bez chesti”. Hronika katastrofy [Leo Tolstoy. “A Prophet Without Honor”. Chronicle of the Catastrophe]. Moscow: Eksmo. (In Rus.)

Poltoratsky, N. P., 1975. I. A. Il’in i polemika vokrug ego idei o soprotivlenii zlu siloi [I. A. Ilyin and the Controversy about His Ideas of Resistance to Evil by Force]. London (Canada): Zarya. (In Rus.)

Sidorin, V. V., 2021. Semyon Liudvigovich Frank. In: A. V. Chernjaev and T. G. Shchedrina, eds. 2021. Institut nauchnoi filosofii. Nachalo [The Institute of Scientific Philosophy. The Beginning]. Moscow: Politicheskaya entsiklopediya, pp. 82-91. (In Rus.)

Solovyov, V., 1918. The Justification of the Good: An Essay on Moral Philosophy. Translated by N. Duddington with a note by S. Graham. London: Constable and Company LTD.

Tolstoy, L., 1904a. My Religion. In: The Complete Works of Count Tolstoy. Translated and edited by L. Wiener. Volume XVI. Boston: Dana Estes & Company, pp. 3-221.

Tolstoy, L., 1904b. Critique of Dogmatic Theology. In: The Complete Works of Count Tolstoy. Translated and edited by L. Wiener. Volume XIII. Boston: Dana Estes & Company, pp. 91-451.

Trubetskoi, E. N., 1911. V. S. Solovyov’s Personality. In: Sbornik pervyi. O Vladimire Solovyove [The First Collection. On Vladimir Solovyov], 1911. Moscow: Put’, pp. 45-74. (In Rus.)

Trubetskoi, E. N., 1912. Tolstoy and Solovyov’s Dispute about the State. In: Sbornik vtoroi. O religii L’va Tolstogo [The Second Collection. On Lev Tolstoi’s Religion], 1912. Moscow: Put’, pp. 59-75. (In Rus.)