The Baltic Region

2012 Issue №1(11)

Back to the list Download an article

Lithuania of the 11th—14th centuries in the works of Russian historians of the 1850—1870s

DOI
10.5922/2079-8555-2012-1-13
Pages
108-115

Abstract

The article analyses the works on the history of medieval Lithuania (11th—14th centuries) by I. D. Belyaev, K. N. Bestuzhev-Ryumin, N. I. Kostomarov and M. O. Koyalovitch. It focuses on Russian scholars’ perception of Lithuania in 1850—870. Employing the comparative historical method and content analysis, the authors identify the key characteristics underlying the perception of Lithuania in research discourse in the 1850s—1870s. Particular attention is paid to an analysis of preconceptions that affected the presentation of Lithuania’s past by Russian historians who studied it in the context of history of western Russia rather than as an independent subject. Special attention is paid to the process of formation of the Grand Duchy of Lithuania. The Lithuanian State of the 14th century is perceived as "ours" in the historiography of the second half of the 19th century. The main thesis of Russian scholars — in line with their Slavophil positions — is that Russian culture is more developed than Lithuanian and more perspective for the Balts than the Polish one.

Reference

1. Beljaev, I. D. 1872, Istorija Polocka, ili Severo-Zapadnoj Rusi, ot drevnejshih vremjon do Ljublinskoj unii. In: Rasskazy iz russkoj istorii [Stories of Russian history], part. 4, Saint Petersburg, Sinodal'naja tipografija.
2. Bestuzhev-Rjumin, K. N. 1872, Russkaja istorija [Russian history], part. 1, Saint Petersburg, Tipografija A. Transhelja.
3. Bestuzhev-Rjumin, K. N. 1885, Russkaja istorija [Russian history], part. 2, Saint Petersburg, Tipografija A. Transhelja.
4. Bestuzhev-Rjumin, K. N. 1989, Recenzija na knigu P. D. Brjanceva «Istorija litovskogo gosudarstva s drevnejshih vremen» [Book Review PD Bryantseva "Lithuanian history from ancient times"], Zhurnal ministerstva narodnogo prosvewenija,
May, p. 492—505.
5. Dvornichenko, A. Ju. 2004, Istoriografija Velikogo knjazhestva Litovskogo i «Ocherk istorii Litovsko-Russkogo gosudarstva «M. K. Ljubavskogo. In: Ljubavskij, M. K. Ocherk istorii Litovsko-Russkogo gosudarstva [Essay on the History of the Lithuanian-Russian state], Saint Petersburg, Nauka, p. 14—30.
6. Dvornichenko, A. Ju. 1993, Russkie zemli Velikogo knjazhestva Litovskogo (do nachala XVI v.). In: Ocherki istorii obwiny, soslovij, gosudarstvennosti [Essays on the history of the community, social classes, the state], Saint Petersburg, Izdatel'stvo Sankt-Peterburgskogo universiteta.
7. Kireeva, R. A. 1990, K. N. Bestuzhev-Rjumin i istoricheskaja nauka vtoroj poloviny XIX v. [K. N. Bestuzhev-Rumin and history of the second half of XIX century.], Moscow, Nauka.
8. Kostomarov, N. I. 1860, Russkie inorodcy. Litovskoe plemja i otnoshenie ego k russkoj istorii [Russian aliens. Lithuanian tribe and its relation to Russian history], Russkoe slovo, no. 5, p. 1—100.
9. Kojalovich, M. O. 2006, Chtenija po istorii zapadnoj Rossii [Readings on the history of western Russia], Minsk, Belaruskaja Jencyklapedyja.
10. Litvak, B. G. 1992, Nikolaj Ivanovich Kostomarov [Nikolai Kostomarov]. In: Kostomarov, N. I. Ocherk domashnej zhizni i nravov velikorusskogo naroda v XVI i XVII stoletijah [Sketch of home life and manners of the people of the Great in
the XVI and XVII centuries], Moscow, Respublika, p. 5—107.
11. Picheta, V. I. 1961, Belorussija i Litva XV-XVI vv. [Belarus and Lithuania XV-XVI centuries], Moscow, Akademija Nauk SSSR.
12. Ulawik, N. N. 1985, Vvedenie v izuchenie belorussko-litovskogo letopisanija [Introduction to the study of the Belarusian-Lithuanian chronicles], Moscow, Nauka.
13. Ustrjalov, N. G. 1839, Issledovanie voprosa, kakoe mesto v russkoj istorii dolzhno zanimat' Velikoe knjazhestvo Litovskoe [An investigation of the place in Russian history should occupy the Grand Duchy of Lithuania], Saint Petersburg, Tipografija
Jekspedicii zagotovlenija gosudarstvennyh bumag.
14. Ustrjalov, N. G. 1855, Russkaja istorija [Russian history], part. 1, Saint Petersburg, Tipografija Apollona Fridrihsona.