Current issue

“The Great Rationalist”: Alexey Vvedensky on Kant in the Context of Russian Kantiana

DOI

10.5922/0207-6918-2024-1-7

Pages

149-180

Abstract

In 1904, the last January issue of the newspaper “Moskoskiye vedomosti” carried an article by Alexey I. Vvedensky, philosopher and theologian, Professor of the Moscow Theological Academy, entitled “The Great Rationalist. On the Centenary of Kant’s Death”. Although the publication could hardly be called unique for its time, as many Russian philosophers and journalists commented on this date, the article merits attention because of the way it represents Kant, and the fact that it sheds light on Vvedensky’s attitudes toward Kantian philosophy. Alexey Vvedensky is to this day a little-known figure in the history of Russian philosophy, such that I thought it would be helpful to preface the publication with a review of the landmarks in the Russian philosopher’s intellectual biography. I go on to demonstrate the ambivalent character of Vvedensky’s attitudes toward Kant’s philosophy. To this end, I show that the Russian philosopher, on one hand, calls for a “return to the universally acclaimed Kant”, whose genius he unreservedly recognises; and on the other hand, he argues that Kant should not only be studied and profoundly reflected on, but also overcome because his rationalism “has desiccated the thought of the new cultured humanity”.

Reference

Abramov, A. I. and Vanchugov, V. V., 2010. Vvedensky Aleksey Ivanovich. In: V. S. Stepin, ed. Novaia filosofskaia ėntsiklopediia [New Philosophical Encyclopedia]: in 4 vol. Volume 1. Moscow: Mysl’, pp. 372-373. (In Rus.)

Anon., 1874. A Few Words About P. D. Yurkevich. Moskovskie vedomosti, 278, pp. 2-3. (In Rus.)

Anon., 1898. Zhurnaly sobranij Soveta Imperatorskoj Moskovskoj duhovnoj akademii 1897 g. [Journals of the Meetings of the Council of the Imperial Moscow Theological Academy in 1897]. Sergiev Posad: 2-ya tipografiya A. I. Snegirevoi. (In Rus.)

Anon., 1905. Immanuel Kant. Niva, 4, pp. 76-77. (Portrait and drawing on p. 75). (In Rus.)

Anon., 1912. From Academic Life (25th Anniversary of Professor A. I. Vvedensky). Bogoslovskiy vestnik [Theological Bulletin], 1(2), pp. 394-454 (3rd pagin.). (In Rus.)

Arnold, T., 2022. Plato’s Ideas in Lotze’s Light — On Husserl’s Reading of Lotze’s Logik. Husserl Studies, 39(1), pp. 85-99. http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s10743-022-09319-z.

Baum, M., 2019. Kants praktischer Platonismus. Kantian Journal, 38(4), pp. 7-33. http://dx.doi.org/10.5922/0207- 6918-2019-4-1.

Dmitrieva, N. A., 2014. The “Perpetual Peace” of Immanuel Kant at the Turn of the Centuries and During the First World War. Prepodavatel XXI vek, 2/1, pp. 46-61. (In Rus.)

Ern, V. F., 1910. Berkeley as the Founder of Modern Immanentism. Voprosy filosofii i psihologii [Issues of Philosophy and Psychology], 103, pp. 413-436. (In Rus.)

Ern, V. F., 1912. Critique of the Kantian Concept of Truth. In: Filosofskij sbornik. L’vu Mihajlovichu Lopa­tinu k tridcatiletiyu nauchno-pedagogicheskoj deyatel’nosti. Ot Moskovskogo psihologicheskogo obshchestva. 1881-1911 [Philosophical Collection. To Lev Mikhailovich Lopatin for Thirty Years of Scientific and Pedagogical Activity. From the Moscow Psychological Society]. Moscow: Tipo-lit. t-va I. N. Kushnereva, pp. 49-61. (In Rus.)

Ern, V. F., 1991a. From Kant to Krupp. In: V. F. Ern, 1991. Sochineniya [Works]. Moscow: Pravda, pp. 308-318. (In Rus.)

Ern, V. F., 1991b. The Essence of German Phenomenalism. In: V. F. Ern, 1991. Sochineniya [Works]. Moscow: Pravda, pp. 319-328. (In Rus.)

Florensky, P. A., 1909. Cosmological Antinomies of I. Kant: [Test Lecture]. Bogoslovskiy vestnik [Theological Bulletin], 1(4), pp. 596-625 (3rd pagin.). (In Rus.)

Flyaksberger, V. A., 1904. Kant’s Philosophy. Zapiski Obshchestva istorii, filologii i prava pri Varshavskom universitete [Proceedings of the Society of History, Philology and Law at the University of Warsaw], 3, pp. 107-150. (In Rus.)

Fouillée, A., 1904a. Nietzsche’s Religion in a Critical Presentation by Alfred Fouillée (Translation from French by D. Vvedensky). Vera i razum [Faith and Reason], 1, pp. 36-48. (In Rus.) (2nd pagin.). (In Rus.)

Fouillée, A., 1904b. Nietzsche’s Religion in a Critical Presentation by Alfred Fouillée (Translation from French by D. Vvedensky) (Ending). Vera i razum [Faith and Reason], 4, pp. 148-170. (In Rus.) (2nd pagin.). (In Rus.)

Fouillée, A., 1905. Nietzsche i immoralizm [Nietzsche and Immoralism]. St. Petersburg : izd-e Obshchestvennoy pol’zy. (In Rus.)

Fouillée, A., 2006. Nietzsche i immoralizm [Nietzsche and Immoralism], translation from French by A. I. Vvedensky. Moscow: URSS, Lenand. (In Rus.)

Howell, R., 2017. Analytical Work on Kant-Idealism, Things-in-Themselves and the Object of Knowledge. Kantian Journal, 36(4), pp. 31-50. http://dx.doi.org/10.5922/0207-6918-2017-4-3. (In Rus.)

Kalinnikov, L. A., 1997. Russian Thought Between Plato and Kant: P. D. Yurkevich. Kantian Journal, 20(1), pp. 75-96. (In Rus.)

Kant, I., 1992. The Jäsche Logic. In: I. Kant, 1992. Lectures on Logic. Translated and edited by J. M. Young. Cambridge.

Kant, I., 1905. Physical Monadology (Translated from German by P. A. Florensky). Bogoslovskiy vestnik [Theological Bulletin], 3(9), pp. 95-127 (3rd pagin.). (In Rus.)

Kant, I., 1997. Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals. Translated and edited by M. J. Gregor, Introduction by C. M. Korsgaard. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Kant, I., 1998. Critique of Pure Reason. Translated and edited by P. Guyer and A. Wood. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Kant, I., 2002. Critique of Practical Reason. Translated by W. S. Pluhar, Introduction by S. Engstrom. Indianapo­lis & Cambridge: Hackett Publishing Company Inc.

Lebedev, V., 1874. Memories of P. D. Yurkevich. Moskovskie vedomosti, 292, p. 4. (In Rus.)

Lotze, H., 1912. Logik: Drei Bücher vom Denken, vom Untersuchen und vom Erkennen. Leipzig: Meiner.

Mirtov, D. P., 1905. Moral Autonomy According to Kant and Nietzsche: a Speech Intended to be Delivered on the Day of the Annual Academic Act. Christian Read­ing, 3, pp. 313-337. (In Rus.)

Natorp, P., 1921. Platos Ideenlehre: eine Einführung in den Idealismus. Leipzig: Meiner.

Nemeth, T., 2023. Philosophy in Imperial Russia’s Theological Academies. Berlin & Boston: Walter de Gruyter.

Pavlov, A. T., 2007. P.D. Yurkevich at Moscow University. Vestnik Moskovskogo universiteta. Seriya 7: Filosofiya [Bulletin of Moscow University. Series 7: Philosophy], 3, pp. 97-108. (In Rus.)

Rohlf, M., 2023. Immanuel Kant. In: E. N. Zalta and U. Nodelman, eds. 2023. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Available at: https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/kant/ (Accessed 23 November 2023).

Rozhin, D. O., 2021. Reception of Kant’s Epistemological Ideas in Fyodor Golubinsky’s Meta­physics. Kantian Journal, 40(1), pp. 97-123. http://dx.doi.org/10.5922/0207-6918-2021-1-3.

Rozhin, D. O., 2023. Between Kant and Trendelenburg: On the Genealogy of Kudryavtsev-Platonov’s Theory of Cognition. Kantian Journal, 42(4), pp. 35-68. http://dx.doi.org/10.5922/0207-6918-2023-4-3.

S. V., 1904. Stat’ya S. V. po povodu 100-letiya smerti Immanuila Kanta [Article by S. V. on the Occasion of the 100th Anniversary of the Death of Immanuel Kant]. In: State Archive of the Russian Federation (GARF), F. 588 (Boris V. Nikolsky). Inv. 1, № 1359. (In Rus.)

Shpet, G. G., 1914. The Philosophical Legacy of P. D. Yurkevich. (On the Fortieth Anniversary of His Death). Voprosy filosofii i psihologii [Issues of Philosophy and Psychology], 125(5), pp. 653-727. (In Rus.)

Smirnov, I. K., 1914. Moscow Theological Academy in 1854-58. From the Memoirs of Iv. Kuzm. Smirnov. In: U Troicy v Akademii. 1814 — 1914 gg. [At the Trinity in the Academy. 1814—1914]. Moscow: Izd. byvsh. vospitannikov Mosk. duhov. akad., pp. 131-140. (In Rus.)

Solovyov, V. S., 1900. Three Characteristics. — M. M. Troickij. — N. Ya. Grot. — P.D. Yurkevich. Vestnik Evropy [Bulletin of Europe], 1, pp. 319-335. (In Rus.)

Vvedensky, Alexey I., 1891. Basic Epistemological Principles of Post-Kantian Philosophy. Historical-critical Essay. Vera i razum [Faith and Reason], 19, pp. 305-326 (2nd pagin.). (In Rus.)

Vvedensky, Alexey I., 1892. Fouillée and the Metaphysics of the Future. Voprosy filosofii i psihologii [Issues of Philosophy and Psychology], 11, pp. 1-30. (In Rus.)

Vvedensky, Alexey I., 1893a. On the Tasks of Modern Philosophy, in Connection with the Question of the Possibility and Direction of Original Russian Philosophy. Voprosy filosofii i psihologii [Issues of Philosophy and Psychology], 20, pp. 125-157. (In Rus.)

Vvedensky, Alexey I., 1893b. Essay on Modern French Philosophy. Philosophy in Modern France. Vera i razum [Faith and Reason], 10, pp. 429-470 (2nd pagin.). (In Rus.)

Vvedensky, Alexey I., 1894. Philosophy of the Future in Germany. Bogoslovskij vestnik [Theological Bulletin], 1(1), pp. 77-99 (1st pagin.). (In Rus.)

Vvedensky, Alexey I., 1895a. [Book Review:] Windelband. History of New Philosophy: Kant’s Philosophy, translated from German by N. Platonova. St. Petersburg 1895. Pages IV+202. Bogoslovskij vestnik [Theological Bulletin], 4(10), pp. 119-125 (3rd pagin.). (In Rus.)

Vvedensky, Alexey I., 1895b. Kant’s Doctrine of Space: (Explanation and Criticism). Bogoslovskij vestnik [Theological Bulletin], 2(6), pp. 390-404 (3rd pagin.). (In Rus.)

Vvedensky, Alexey I., 1904. Great Rationalist. On the Centenary of Kant’s Death. (1704 — January 31 — 1804). Moskovskie vedomosti [Moscow News], 31, pp. 3-4. (In Rus.)

Vvedensky, Alexey I., 1909. Socializm, kak nravstvennaya i teoreticheskaya zadacha [Socialism as a Moral and Theoretical Task]. Second Edition. Moscow: “Russkaya Pechatnya”. (In Rus.)

Vvedensky, Alexey I., 2015. Zapadnaya dejstvitel’nost’ i russkie idealy: Pis’ma iz-za granicy [Western Reality and Russian Ideals: Letters from Abroad]. Moscow: LENAND. (In Rus.)

Windelband, W., 1880. Die Geschichte der Neueren Philosophie. Volume 2: Von Kant bis Hegel und Herbart. Leipzig: Breitkopf und Härtel.

Windelband, W., 1895. Filosofiya Kanta (Iz istorii novoj filosofii Windelbanda) [Philosophy of Kant (From the History of the New Philosophy of Windelband)]. Translated from German by N. Platonova. St. Petersburg : Tip. I. N. Skorohodova. (In Rus.)

Yermishin, O. T., 2009. Vvedensky Aleksey Ivanovich. In: Patriarch of Moscow and All Rus’ Kirill, ed. 2009. Pravoslavnaya enciklopediya [Orthodox Encyclopedia]. Available at: https://www.pravenc.ru/text/149991.html (Accessed 23 November 2023) (In Rus.)

Yungerov, P. A., ed. 2007. Kniga Bytiya. Opyt perelozheniya na russkij yazyk [Book of Genesis. Experience of Transposition into Russian]. Translated by P. A. Yungerov, reprinted by N. Divakov. Moscow: Izdanie KB MDA i Fonda “Serafim”. Available at: Azbuka very <https://azbyka.ru/otechnik/Pavel_Yungerov/kniga-bytija/3&gt; (Accessed 23 November 2023) (In Rus.)

Yurkevich, P. D., 1860. From the Science of the Human Spirit. Trudy Kievskoj duhovnoj akademii [Proceedings of the Kyiv Theological Academy], 4, pp. 367-511. (In Rus.)

Yurkevich, P. D., 1865. Reason According to the Teachings of Plato and Experience According to the Teachings of Kant. Speech by Ordinary Professor P. D. Yurkevich. Moskovskie Universitetskie Izvestiya [Moscow University News], 5, pp. 321-392. (In Rus.)

Zen’kovsky, V. V., 1908. Plato in the Interpretation by P. Natorp. Voprosy filosofii i psihologii [Issues of Philosophy and Psychology], 95, pp. 588-619 (2nd pagin.). (In Rus.)

Žust, M. M., 2002. À la recherche de la vérité vivante. Roma: Lipa Srl.