Kant as the German Theorist of the French Revolution: the Origin of a Dogma
- DOI
- 10.5922/0207-6918-2021-3-3
- Pages
- 63-92
Abstract
The origins in Marxist-Leninist philosophy of the dogma about Kant as the German theorist of the French Revolution requires some analysis and I explain how a phrase of Marx later gave rise to the dogma. I first look at the sources that influenced K. Marx’s view of Kant and the French Revolution, above all С. F. Bachmann and H. Heine. I then examine the form in which Kant’s philosophy was compared with the French Revolution in the non-Bolshevik milieu before the 1917 Russian Revolution (P. Ya. Chaadayev, V. S. Mezhevich, the Dostoyevsky brothers, V. F. Ern, Archbishop Nikanor, P. A. Florensky). Then I look at how Marx’s phrase influenced Russian social democrats and specifically the Bolsheviks (G. V. Plekhanov, V. I. Lenin, V. M. Shulyatikov). I cite the example of the discussion triggered by a letter of Z. Ya. Beletsky concerning the third volume of The History of Philosophy (1943) to demonstrate the non-canonical status of Marx’s thesis on Kant and the French Revolution in the Soviet Union in the first half of the twentieth century. Finally, the first Soviet edition of Kant’s works in the 1960s canonised Marx’s phrase and gave the exact source. The reason why it took so long to give chapter and verse for the Marx quotation is that it occurs as early as 1842 in “The Philosophical Manifesto of the Historical School of Law” which belongs to the idealistic period of the early Marx.
Reference
Aldanov, M. A., 2002. The Ninth Thermidor. In: M A. Aldanov, 2002. Myslitelʼ: Devjatoe termidora. Chertov most. Zagovor. Svjataja Elena, malenʼkij ostrov. Tetralogija [The Thinker: The Ninth Thermidor. Devilʼs Bridge. Conspiracy. St. Helena, the Little Island. Tetralogy]. Moscow: Zakharov, pp. 5-196. (In Rus.)
[Aleksandrov, G. F., Bykhovsky, B. E., Mitin, M. B. and Judin, P. F.], eds. 1943. From the Editors. In: Istorija filosofii [History of Philosophy]. Volume 3: Filosofija pervoj poloviny XIX veka [Philosophy in the First Half of the 19th Century]. Moscow: OGIZ Gospolitizdat, p. 2. (In Rus.)
Aleksandrov, G. F., 1946. Istorija zapadnoevropejskoj filosofii [History of West European Philosophy]. Moscow and Leningrad: Izdatelʼstvo AN SSSR. (In Rus.)
Aleksandrov, G. F., 2003a. Letter to G. M. Malenkov and A. S. Scherbakov of 29 February 1944. In: A. D. Kosichev, 2003. Filosofija, vremja, ljudi. Vospominanija i razmyshlenija dekana filosof-skogo fakulʼteta MGU im. M. V. Lomonosova [Philosophy, Time, People. Memories and Reflections of the Dean of Philosophy Faculty of Lomonosov Moscow State University]. Moscow: OLMA-PRESS, pp. 83-91. (In Rus.)
Aleksandrov, G. F., 2003b. Letter to G. M. Malenkov and A. S. Scherbakov of 3 May 1944. In: A. D. Kosichev, 2003. Filosofija, vremja, ljudi. Vospominanija i razmyshlenija dekana filosof-skogo fakulʼteta MGU im. M. V. Lomonosova [Philosophy, Time, People. Memories and Reflections of the Dean of Philosophy Faculty of Lomonosov Moscow State University]. Moscow: OLMA-PRESS, pp. 106-107. (In Rus.)
Anonym, 1794. Dreyerley Desorganisationen gegen das Ende unseres Jahrhunderts. Philosophisches Archiv, hg. von J. A. Eberhard (Berlin). Band 2, St. 3, pp. 17-31.
Anonym, 1795. Gespräch zwischen Charlotte Cordé, der Mörderin des berüchtigten Marat zu Paris, und einem kritischen Philosophen. Philosophisches Archiv, hg. von J. A. Eberhard (Berlin). Band 2, St. 4, pp. 110-113.
Asmus, V. F., 1936. Philosophical Culture under the Boots of Fascism. In: Znamja [Banner], 3, pp. 189-222. (In Rus.)
Asmus, V. F., 1942. Fashistskaja falʼsifikacija klassicheskoj nemeckoj filosofii [The Fascist Falsification of Classical German Philosophy]. Moscow: OGIZ Gospolitizdat. (In Rus.)
[Asmus, V. F.], 1943. Kant. In: G. F. Aleksandrov, B. E. Bykhovsky, M. B. Mitin and P. F. Judin, eds. 1943. Istorija filosofii [History of Philosophy]. Volume 3: Filosofija pervoj poloviny XIX veka [Philosophy in the First Half of the 19th Century]. Moscow: OGIZ Gospolitizdat, pp. 56-137. (In Rus.)
Bachmann, C. F., 1816. Über die Philosophie meiner Zeit. Zur Vermittlung. Jena: Cröker.
Bammel, G. K., 1936. On the Fascization of the History of Philosophy in Germany. In: I. N. Dvorkin, A. M. Deborin, M. D. Kammari, M. B. Mitin, M. A. Saveliev, eds. 1936. Protiv fashistskogo mrakobesija i demagogii. Sbornik statej [Against Fascist Obscurantism and Demagogy. Collected Papers]. Moscow: Gosudarstvennoe socialʼno-jekonomicheskoe izdatelʼstvo, pp. 216-264. (In Rus.)
Beletsky, Z. Ya., 2003. Letter to I. V. Stalin of 27 January 1944. In: A. D. Kosichev, 2003. Filosofija, vremja, ljudi. Vospominanija i razmyshlenija dekana filosof-skogo fakulʼteta MGU im. M. V. Lomonosova [Philosophy, Time, People. Memories and Reflections of the Dean of Philosophy Faculty of Lomonosov Moscow State University]. Moscow: OLMA-PRESS, pp. 245-320. (In Rus.)
Beletsky, Z. Ya., 1947. [Talk]. In: Voprosy filosofii, 1, pp. 314-325. (In Rus.)
Bernhard, T., 1983. Immanuel Kant. In: T. Bernhard, 1983. Die Stücke 1969–1981. Frankfurt a. M.: Suhrkamp, pp. 595-684.
Bonsens, E. [Brosse, F. C.], 1798. Antipseudo-Kantiade, oder der Leinweber und sein Sohn, ein satyrisch-kritischer Roman, mit imaginierten Kupfern, ohne Vorrede von Kant, aber mit einer üblen Nachrede der Pseudokantianer. Gnidos [Riga]: Severesto.
[Bykhovsky, B. E.?], 1943. Hegel. In: G. F. Aleksandrov, B. E. Bykhovsky, M. B. Mitin and P. F. Judin, eds. 1943. Istorija filosofii [History of Philosophy]. Volume 3: Filosofija pervoj poloviny XIX veka [Philosophy in the First Half of the 19th Century]. Moscow: OGIZ Gospolitizdat, pp. 210-301. (In Rus.)
Central Committee of the All-Union Communist Party of Bolsheviks, 1944. On the Shortcomings and Errors in the Coverage of the History of German Philosophy in the Late Eighteenth and Early Nineteenth Centuries. Bolshevik, 7-8, pp. 14-19. (In Rus.)
Chaadaev, P. Ya., 1991. Letter to A. I. Turgenev of October — November 1835. In: P. Ya. Chaadaev, 1991. Polnoe sobranie sochinenij i izbrannye pisʼma v 2-h t. [Complete Works and Selected Letters in 2 Volumes]. Volume 2. Moscow: Nauka, pp. 94-101. (In Rus.)
Deborin, A. M., 1927. Revisionism under the Mask of Orthodoxy. Pod znamenem marksizma [Under the Banner of Marxism], 9, pp. 5-48. (In Rus.)
Engels, F., 1975. Progress of Social Reform on the Continent. In: K. Marx and F. Engels, 1975. Collected Works. Volume 3: Marx and Engels: 1843–1844. Moscow: Progress Publishers; London: Lawrence & Wishart, pp. 392-408.
Engels, F., 1989. Preface to the First German Edition of Socialism: Utopian and Scientific. In: K. Marx and F. Engels, 1989. Collected Works. Volume 24: Marx and Engels: 1874–1883. London: Lawrence & Wishart, pp. 457-459.
Engels, F., 1990. Ludwig Feuerbach and the End of Classical German Philosophy. In: K. Marx and F. Engels, 1990. Collected Works. Volume 26: Engels: 1882–1889. London: Lawrence & Wishart, pp. 353-398.
Ern, V. F., 1991. The Sword and the Cross (From Kant to Krupp). In: V. F. Ern, 1991. Sochinenija [Works]. Moscow: “Pravda”, pp. 308-318. (In Rus.)
Fichte, J. G., 1970. Brief an J. I. Baggesen vom April 1795. In: J. G. Fichte, 1970. Gesamtausgabe der Bayerischen Akademie der Wissenschaften. Band III, 2. Stuttgart-Bad Cannstatt: Frommann-Holzboog, p. 298.
Florensky, P. A., 2007. From Lectures on the History of Philosophy in Modern Times. Russian Journal of Philosophical Sciences, 1, pp. 20-44. (In Rus.)
[Francke, R. and Hollmer, H.], eds. 2001. Mitteilungen. In: H. Heine, 2001. Säkularausgabe: Werke, Briefwechsel, Lebenszeugnisse. Band 8: Über Deutschland 1833–1836. Kunst und Philosophie. Kommentar. Herausgegeben von der Stiftung Weimarer Klassik. Berlin: Akademie Verlag, pp. 372-568.
Heine, H., 1864. Traits from the History of Religion and Philosophy in Germany. In: Jepoha, zhurnal literaturnyj i politicheskij [Epoch, Journal of Literature and Politics], edited by M. M. Dostoevsky (St. Petersburg), 3, pp. 192-222. (In Rus.)
Heine, H., 2007a. From the Introduction to “Kahldorf on the Nobility in Letters to Count M. von Moltke (1831). In: H. Heine, 2007. On the History of Religion and Philosophy in Germany and Other Writings. Edited by T. Pinkard, translated by H. Pollack-Milgate. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 130-135.
Heine, H., 2007b. On the History of Religion and Philosophy in Germany. In: H. Heine, 2007. On the History of Religion and Philosophy in Germany and Other Writings. Edited by T. Pinkard, translated by H. Pollack-Milgate. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 3-117.
Herzen, A., 1956. Letters on the Study of Nature. Letter Eight: Realism. In: A. Herzen, 1956. Selected Philosophical Works. Moscow: Foreign Languages Publishing House, pp. 282-305.
Herzen, A., 1982. My Past and Thoughts. The Memories. Translated by C. Garnett, revised by H. Higgens, Introduction by I. Berlin, abridged, with a preface and notes by D. Macdonald. Berkeley & Los Angeles & London: University of California Press.
[Huber, L. F.], 1796. Projet de paix perpétuelle, par Kant. In: Gazette nationale ou le Moniteur universel, 103 (3 January), pp. 410-411.
Kant, I., 1998. Critique of Pure Reason. Translated and edited by P. Guyer and A. W. Wood. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Klopstock, F. G., 1982. Werke und Briefe. Historisch-kritische Ausgabe. Werke 1: Epigramme. Herausgegeben von K. Hurlebusch. Berlin: De Gruyter.
Krouglov, A. N., 2010. “Sitting Behind a Screen...”: Alexander Blok and Andrei Bely. In: I. N. Griftsova and N. A. Dmitrieva, 2010. Neokantianstvo nemetskoe i russkoe: mezhdu teoriej poznaniya i kritikoj kul’tury [German and Russian Neo-Kantianism: Between Theory of Knowledge and Criticism of Culture]. Мoscow: Russian Political Encyclopedia (ROSSPEN), pp. 484-499.
Krouglov, A. N., 2018. Der Streit der russischen Marxisten um Kants Ethik. Studies in East European Thought, 70, pp. 249-261.
Krouglov, A. N., 2020. Discussion about Kant during the Great Patriotic War: The Look 75 Years after the Victory. Part II. In: Voprosy Filosofii, 6, pp. 169-189. (In Rus.)
Lenin, V. I., 1977a. The Three Sources and Three Component Parts of Marxism. In: V. I. Lenin, 1977. Collected Works. Volume 19: March — December 1913. Moscow: Progress Publishers, pp. 21-28.
Lenin, V. I., 1977b. Materialism and Empirio-Criticism. Critical Comments on a Reactionary Philosophy. In: V. I. Lenin, 1977. Collected Works. Volume 14: 1908. Moscow: Progress Publishers, pp. 17-388.
Lenin, V. I., 1977c. Philosophical Notebooks. In: V. I. Lenin, 1977. Collected Works. Volume 38. Moscow: Progress Publishers.
Luppol, I. K., 1930. Kant and Modern Revisionism in German Social Democracy (K. Vorländer and M. Adler). In: Na dva fronta. Sbornik statej [On Two Fronts. Collection of Papers]. Moscow and Leningrad: Gosudarstvennoe izdatelʼstvo, pp. 113-137. (In Rus.)
Marx, K., 1975. The Philosophical Manifesto of the Historical School of Law. In: K. Marx and F. Engels, 1975. Collected Works. Volume 1: Marx, 1835–1843. Moscow: Progress Publishers; London: Lawrence & Wishart, pp. 203-210.
Mezhevich, V. S., 1833. Hegel. In: Teleskop. Zhurnal sovremennogo prosveshchenija [Telescope. Journal of Contemporary Enlightenment Telescope. Journal of Contemporary Enlightenment], edited by N. I. Nadezhdin, 16(15), pp. 381-397. (In Rus.)
Mitin, M. B., ed. 1934. Dialekticheskij i istoricheskij materializm v 2-h chastjah. Uchebnik dlja komvuzov i vtuzov. Part 1: Dialekticheskij materializm [Dialectical and Historical Materialism in 2 Parts. Textbook for colleges and universities. Part 1: Dialectical Materialism]. Moscow: OGIZ Socjekgiz. (In Rus.)
Moshkovskaya, Ju. Ja., 1941. [Kant]. In: V. P. Volgin and E. V. Tarle, eds. 1941. Francuzskaja burzhuaznaja revoljucija. 1769–1794. [The French Bourgeois Revolution. 1769–1794]. Moscow and Leningrad: Izdatelʼstvo AN SSSR, pp. 245-250. (In Rus.)
Nikanor, arhiepiskop (Brovkovich, A. I.), 1888. Pozitivnaja filosofija i sverhchuvstvennoe bytie. Tom 3: Kritika na kritiku chistogo razuma Kanta [Positive Philosophy and Supersensible Being. Volume 3: Critique on Kant’s Critique of Pure Reason]. St. Petersburg: “Obshchestvennaja polʼza”. (In Rus.)
Oizerman, T. I., 1955. Nemeckaja klassicheskaja filosofija — odin iz teoreticheskih istochnikov marksizma [Classical German Philosophy is One of the Theoretical Sources of Marxism]. Moscow: “Znanie”. (In Rus.)
Oizerman, T. I., 1963. Immanuel Kant, Pioneer of Classical German Philosophy. In: I. Kant, 1963. Sochinenija v shesti tomah [Works in Six Volumes], Volume 1. Edited by V. F. Asmus, A. V. Gulyga and T. I. Oizerman. Moscow: “Myslʼ”, pp. 5-67. (In Rus.)
Oizerman, T. I., 2005. Opravdanie revizionizma [The Justification of Revisionism]. Moscow: Kanon+. (In Rus.)
Philonenko, A., 1972. L’oeuvre de Kant: la philosophie critique. Tome II. Paris: J. Vrin.
Pisarev, D. I., 2005. Heinrich Heine. In: D. I. Pisarev, 2005. Polnoe sobranie sochinenij i pisem v 12-ti t. [Complete Works and Letters in Twelve Volumes]. Volume 9. Moscow: Nauka, pp. 391-440. (In Rus.)
Plekhanov, G. V., 1928. Marxʼs Philosophical Evolution. In: G. V. Plekhanov, 1928. Sochinenija [Works]. Volume 18. Moscow and Leningrad: Gosudarstvennoe izdatel’stvo, pp. 323-334. (In Rus.)
Plekhanov, G. V., 1974a. Cant against Kant or Herr Bernstein’s Will and Testament. In: G. V. Plekhanov, 1974. Selected Philosophical Works, Volume 2. Moscow: Progress Publishers, pp. 352-378.
Plekhanov, G. V., 1974b. [Foreword to the First Edition (“From the Translator”) and Plekhanov’s Notes to Engels’ Book Ludwig Feuerbach and the End of Classical German Philosophy]. In: G. V. Plekhanov, 1974. Selected Philosophical Works, Volume 1. Moscow: Progress Publishers, pp. 427-476.
Plehanov, G. V., 1976a. Translator’s Preface to the Second Edition of Engels’ Ludwig Feuerbach and the End of Classical German Philosophy. In: G. V. Plekhanov, 1976. Selected Philosophical Works, Volume 3. Moscow: Progress Publishers, pp. 64-83.
Plehanov, G. V., 1976b. On Mr V. Shulyatikov’s Book. In: G. V. Plekhanov, 1976. Selected Philosophical Works, Volume 3. Moscow: Progress Publishers, pp. 299-305.
Razumny, V. A., 2008. The Reality of the Fantastic. Vestnik Rossijskogo filosofskogo obshchestva [Bulletin of the Russian Philosophical Society], 2, pp. 217-220. (In Rus.)
Rosenkranz, K., 1840. Geschichte der Kant’schen Philosophie. In: I. Kant, 1840. Sämtliche Werke, Theil 12. Herausgegeben von K. Rosenkranz und F. W. Schubert. Leipzig: Leopold Voss, pp. 1-496.
Schröpfer, H., 2003. Kants Weg in die Öffentlichkeit: Christian Gottfried Schütz als Wegbereiter der kritischen Philosophie. Stuttgart-Bad Cannstatt: Frommann-Holzboog.
[Schütz, Ch. G.], 1785. Riga, b. Hartknoch: Grundlegung zur Metaphysik der Sitten von Immanuel Kant, 8 Bog. 8. Allgemeine Literatur-Zeitung (Jena), 2(80), p. 21.
Shcheglov, A. V., 1940. Nemeckaja klassicheskaja filosofija (Kant, Gegelʼ, Fejerbakh). Stenogramma lekcij, prochitannyh 11, 14 i 17 dekabrya 1939 g. (Kurs dialekticheskogo i istoricheskogo materializma VPSh pri CK VKP(b)) [Classical German Philosophy (Kant, Hegel, Feuerbach). Transcript of the Lectures Delivered on 11, 14 and 17 December 1939. (Course of Dialectical and Historical Materialism in the High Party School under the Central Committee of the VKP(B))]. Edited by M. B. Mitin. Moscow: s.n. (In Rus.)
Shulyatikov, V. M., 1908. Opravdanie kapitalizma v zapadnoevropejskoj filosofii (ot Dekarta do Je. Maha) [The Justification of Capitalism in Western European Philosophy (from Descartes to E. Mach)]. Moscow: Moskovskoe knigoizdatelʼstvo. (In Rus.)
Stalin, J., 1975. Dialectical and Historical Materialism. Calcutta: Mass Publications.
Tolstoy, A. N., 1947. A Gloomy Morning. In: A. N. Tolstoy, 1947. Polnoe sobranie sochinenij [Complete Works]. Volume 8. Moscow: GIKhL, pp. 7-400. (In Rus.)
Varnhagen von Ense, K. A., 1843. Kant’s Leben, von Schubert. 1842. Aus einem Brief an ** in**. In: K. A. Varnhagen von Ense, 1843. Denkwürdigkeiten und vermischte Schriften. Band 5. Leipzig: F. A. Brockhaus, pp. 751-759.
Varnhagen von Ense, K. A., 1869. Tagebücher. Aus dem Nachlaß Varnhagen’s von Ense. Band 11. Hamburg: Hoffmann & Campe.
Vorländer, K., 1912. Kants Stellung zur französischen Revolution. In: Philosophische Abhandlungen Hermann Cohen zum 70sten Geburtstag (4. Juli 1912) dargebracht. Berlin: Bruno Cassirer, pp. 247-269.
Zhdanov, A. A. 1952. Vystuplenie na diskussii po knige G. F. Aleksandrova “Istorija zapadno-evropejskoj filosofii” 24 iunya 1947 g. [Speech at the Discussion of G. F. Alexandrovʼs Book History of Western European Philosophy on 24 June 1947]. Moscow: Gospolitizdat. (In Rus.)