Fichte’s Ideas in the Philosophical Doctrines of Russian Neo-Kantians
- DOI
- 10.5922/0207-6918-2025-2-5
- Pages
- 101-126
Abstract
Fichte’s doctrine played a significant role in the emergence of Neo-Kantian philosophical projects both in Germany and in Russia. This paper proceeds from the works of Boris Vysheslavtsev, Boris Yakovenko and Henry Lanz and tries to reconstruct the influences exerted by Fichte’s ideas on the philosophical ideas of Russian Neo-Kantians. The historical-philosophical works of Russian Neo-Kantians constitute an integral body which provides an interpretative context of Fichte’s philosophy and forms an inalienable and significant part of Fichte studies in Russia. The main tendency of these works is an attempt to bring Fichte’s doctrine closer to Russian philosophy, to represent his philosophical system in its entirety without dividing it into autonomous periods, drawing attention to the ethical character of his philosophy and stressing the German philosopher’s contribution to the study of the problem of the irrational. The works of Russian Neo-Kantians are characterised by particular attention to Fichte’s ideal-realist ideas, his logicistic approach to absolute being, the attempt to overcome the contradiction between absolute unity and the concrete manifold. Fichte’s idea of the primacy of practical reason, which shaped the image of Fichtean philosophy in Gertman Neo-Kantianism, was taken up and developed in an original way by Russian Neo-Kantians. Vysheslavtsev made a consistent attempt to derive law, the state and economics from the ethical content of epistemology, “the science of knowledge”; Yakovenko suggested interpreting “the science of knowledge” as a teaching on life and freedom, as the philosophical grounding of the Christian idea; Lanz wrote about Fichte’s philosophy in the same vein as “the revolt of morality against theory”, as a philosophy of freedom.
Reference
Abaschnik, V.A., 2013. Patriot oder Nationalist? Rezeption von Fichtes Reden an die deutsche Nation in Russland und der Ukraine. Fichte-Studien, 38(1), pp. 231-247. https://doi.org/10.1163/18795811_03801015
Dmitrieva, N. A., 2007. Russkoe neokantianstvo: “Marburg” v Rossii. Istoriko-filosofskie ocherki [Russian Neo-Kantianism: “Marburg” in Russia. Historical and Philosophical Essays]. Moscow: Rossiiskaya politicheskaya entsiklopediya (ROSSPEN).
Dmitrieva, N. A. and Popova, O. A., 2008. Lanz Henrich Ernestovich. In: Moskovskaya entsiklopediya [Moscow Encyclopedia], 2008. Volume 1, Book 2. Moscow: Fond “Moskovskie entsiklopedii”, p. 383.
Ermichev, A. A., 2000. On the Neo-Kantian B. V. Yakovenko and His Place in Russian Philosophy. Introductory article. In: B. V. Yakovenko, 2000. Moshch’ filosofii [Power of Philosophy]. Saint-Petersburg: Nauka, pp. 5-42. (In Rus.)
Ermichev, A. A., 2004. Boris Valentinovich Yakovenko — Russian Researcher of J. G. Fichte’s Philosophy. In: B. V. Yakovenko, 2004. Zhizn’ i filosofiya Ioganna Gotliba Fikhte [The Life and Philosophy of Johann Gottlieb Fichte]. Saint-Petersburg: Nauka, pp. 5-34. (In Rus.)
Ermichev, A. A., 2012. Life and Philosophy of Boris Valentinovich Yakovenko. In: A. A. Ermichev, ed. 2012. Boris Valentinovich Yakovenko. Moscow: Rossiiskaya politicheskaya entsiklopediya (ROSSPEN), pp. 71-122. (In Rus.)
Fichte, J. G., 1982. Introduction to the Science of Knowledge. In: J. G. Fichte, 1982. Science of Knowledge. Edited and translated by P. Heath and J. Lachs. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 3-28.
Fichte, J. G., 2005. The Science of Knowing: J. G. Fichte’s 1804 Lectures on the Wissenschaftslehre. Translated by W.E. Wright. Albany, N. Y.: State University of New York Press.
Fichte, J. G., 2021. Foundation of the entire Wissenschaftslehre. In: J. G. Fichte, 2021. Foundation of the Entire Wissenschaftslehre and Related Writings (1794—95). Edited and translated by D. Breazeale. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 196-378.
Ivanenko, A. A., 2013. Das Problem der veränderten Lehre in der russischen Fichte-Forschung. Fichte-Studien, 38(1), pp. 249-256. https://doi.org/10.5840/fichte20133815
Kornilaev, L. Yu., 2022. The Image of Fichte’s Philosophy in German Neo-Kantianism. Kantian Journal, 41(4), pp. 76-93.
Krotkow, W., 2013. Fichtes Einfluss auf die Konzeption des absoluten Realismus von S. L. Frank (philosophisch-politischer Blick). Fichte-Studien, 38(1), pp. 271-275. http://dx.doi.org/10.1163/18795811_03801019
Lanz, H., 1912. Das Problem der Gegenständlichkeit in der modernen Logik. Berlin: Reuter & Reichard, 1912.
Lanz, H., 1913. Fichte und der transzendentale Wahrheitsbegriff. Archiv für Geschichte der Philosophie, 26(1), Neue Folge, 19(1), pp. 1-25.
Lanz, H., 1914a. Being and Knowledge in Fichte’s Philosophy. Voprosy filosofii i psikhologii [Issues of Philosophy and Psychology], 122, pp. 227-282. (In Rus.)
Lanz, H., 1914b. Johann Gottlieb Fichte. Voprosy filosofii i psikhologii [Issues of Philosophy and Psychology], 122, pp. 65-119. (In Rus.)
Lanz, H., 1914c. In Memory of Fichte. Russkaya mysl’ [Russian Thought], 6, pp. 42-51. (In Rus.)
Lanz, H., 1914d. Freedom and Consciousness: (On the Centenary of the Death of J. G. Fichte). Logos, 1(1), pp. 1-23. (In Rus.)
Lanz, H., 1926. The Irrationality of Reasoning. The Philosophical Review, 35(4), pp. 340-359.
Lanz, H., 1941. In Quest of Morals. Stanford: Stanford University Press; London: Oxford University Press.
Lazarev, V. V., 2000. On the Ethical Comprehension of Fichte’s Philosophy in Russia in the Late 19th and early 20th Centuries. In: V. F. Pustarnakov, 2000. Filosofiya Fikhte v Rossii [Fichte’s Philosophy in Russia]. Saint-Petesburg: RKhGI Press, pp. 258-336. (In Rus.)
Lazarev, V. V., 2006. Eticheskaya mysl’ v Germanii i Rossii. Osmyslenie fikhteanstva russkimi filosofami kontsa XIX — nachala XX v. [Ethical Thought in Germany and Russia. Comprehension of Fichteanism by Russian Philosophers of the Late 19th and early 20th Centuries]. Moscow: IF RAN. (In Rus.)
Lomonosov, A. G., 2012. Actualization of J. G. Fichte’s Transcendental Idealism in the Work of B. V. Yakovenko. In: A. A. Ermichev, 2012. Boris Valentinovich Yakovenko. Moscow: Rossiiskaya politicheskaya entsiklopediya (ROSSPEN), pp. 260-287. (In Rus.)
Stolzenberg, J., 2010. Right and Moral. Paul Natorp and Boris Vysheslavtsev’s Interpretation of Kant and Fichte. In: I. N. Griftsova and N. A. Dmitrieva, eds. 2010. Neokantianstvo nemetskoe i russkoe: mezhdu teoriei poznaniya i kritikoi kul’tury [German and Russian Neo-Kantianism: Between Theory of Cognition and Critique of Culture]. Moscow: Rossiiskaya politicheskaya entsiklopediya (ROSSPEN), pp. 317-327. (In Rus.)
Stolzenberg, J., 2024. Recht und Moral. Kant und Fichte im Neukantianismus: Paul Natorp und Boris Wischeslavzeff. Fichte-Studien, 53(2), pp. 395-408. https://doi.org/10.1163/18795811-05302008
Vysheslavtsev, B. P., 1908. Fichte’s Justification of Socialism. Voprosy filosofii i psikhologii, 95, pp. 571-587. (In Rus.)
Vysheslavtsev, B. P., 1914. Etika Fikhte. Osnovy prava i nravstvennosti v sisteme transtsendental’noi filosofii [Fichte’s Ethics. Foundations of Law and Morality in the System of Transcendental Philosophy]. Moscow: Pechatnya A. Snegirevoi. (In Rus.)
Yakovenko, B. V., 2000a. The Path of Philosophical Cognition. In: B. V. Yakovenko, 2000. Moshch’ filosofii [Power of Philosophy]. Saint-Petersburg: Nauka, pp. 244-263. (In Rus.)
Yakovenko, B. V., 2000b. Essence of Pluralism. In: B. V. Yakovenko, 2000. Moshch’ filosofii [Power of Philosophy]. Saint-Petersburg: Nauka, pp. 282-292. (In Rus.)
Yakovenko, B. V., 2004a. Science of Knowledge (An Attempt of Historical and Systematic Study). In: B. V. Yakovenko, 2004. Zhizn’ i filosofiya Ioganna Gotliba Fikhte [Johann Gottlieb Fichte’s Life and Philosophy]. Saint-Petersburg: Nauka, pp. 207-350. (In Rus.)
Yakovenko, B. V., 2004b. The Basic Idea of J. G. Fichte’s Theoretical Philosophy. In: B. V. Yakovenko, 2004. Zhizn’ i filosofiya Ioganna Gotliba Fikhte [Johann Gottlieb Fichte’s Life and Philosophy]. Saint-Petersburg: Nauka, pp. 182-206. (In Rus.)
Zhuchkov, V. A., 2000. Fichte as an Indicator of Contradictions in Russian Philosophy of the Late 19th and early 20th Centuries. In: V. F. Pustarnakov, 2000. Filosofiya Fikhte v Rossii [Fichte’s Philosophy in Russia]. Saint-
Petersburg: RKhGI Press, pp. 212-237. (In Rus.)