The Baltic Region

2016 Issue №2

Back to the list Download the article

Monotowns: A Quantitative Analysis



The authors propose an empirical analysis of the current situation in monotowns. The study questions the perceived seriousness of the ‘monotown problem’ as well as the actual challenges it presents. The authors use a cluster analysis to divide monotowns into groups for further structural comparison. The structural differences in the available databases limit the possibilities of empirical analysis. Hence, alternative approaches are required. The authors consider possible reasons for the limitations identified. Special attention is paid to the monotowns that were granted the status of advanced development territories. A comparative analysis makes it possible to study their general characteristics and socioeconomic indicators. The authors apply the theory of opportunistic behaviour to describe potential problems caused by the lack of unified criteria for granting monotowns the status of advanced development territories. The article identifies the main stakeholders and the character of their interaction; it desc ribes a conceptual model built on the principal/agent interactions, and identifies the parametric space of mutually beneficial cooperation. The solution to the principal/agent problem suggested in the article contributes to the development of an alternative approach to the current situation and a rational approach to overcoming the ‘monotown problem’.


1. Analiticheskij obzor PwC «Avtomobil'nyj rynok Rossii: rezul'taty za 9 mesjacev 2015 g.» [Analytical review PwC «Automotive market of Russia: results for the first 9 months of 2015"], 2015, available at: publications/assets/automotive-nov-2015.pdf (accessed 27.03.2016).
2. Departament truda i zanjatosti naselenija Kemerovskoj oblasti [The Department of Labor and Employment of the Kemerovo Region population], 2015, available at: http://www. aspx (accessed 27.01.2016).
3. Zakon «O territorijah social'no-jekonomicheskogo razvitija v Rossijskoj Federacii » ot 29 dekabrja 2014 g. № 473-FZ [The law "On Territories of socio-economic development in the Russian Federation" dated 29 December 2014 # 473-FZ], 2014.
4. Zubarevich, N. V. 2010, Regiony Rossii: neravenstvo, krizis, modernizacija [Regions of Russia: the inequality crisis, modernization], Moscow, 160 p.
5. Indeks cen na lom cvetnyh metallov na rossijskom rynke v dekabre 2015 g. [The price index for scrap non-ferrous metals in the Russian market in December 2015], 2015, available at: http://www.infogeo. ru/metalls/review/?act=show&rev=1133 (accessed 29.12.2015).
6. Kompleksnyj investicionnyj plan modernizacii monogoroda Novokuzneck [A comprehensive investment plan for the modernization of company towns Novokuznetsk], 2016, available at: (accessed 01.02.2016).
7. Kompleksnyj investicionnyj plan modernizacii monogoroda Noril'ska [A comprehensive investment plan for the modernization of Norilsk monotown], 2015, available at: (accessed 12.12.2015).
8. Obzor rynka chernoj metallurgii za 2015 god [Review of the Steel Market in 2015]. 2015, Deloitte, available at: (accessed 15.02.2016).
9. Obrashhenie general'nogo direktora [Address by Director General], 2009, Norilsk Nickel, available at: (accessed 17.12.2015).
10. Oficial'nyj sajt gosudarstvennoj statistiki RF [The official website of the state statistics], 2015, available at: (accessed 27.10.2015).
11. Oficial'nyj sajt Nizhnekamskogo municipal'nogo rajona Respubliki Tatarstan [The official website of the Nizhnekamsk municipal district of the Republic of Tatarstan], 2015, available at: (accessed 18.03.2016).
12. Oficial'nyj sajt goroda Cherepovec [Official site of Cherepovets], 2016, available at: (accessed 14.01.2016).
13. Rasporjazhenie № 668-p Pravitel'stva RF ot 16 aprelja 2015 g. [Order № 668-p of the RF Government of April 16, 2015], 2015, available at: (accessed 20.10.2015).
14. Rosstat Rostovskoj oblasti RF [The Federal State Statistics Service of the Rostov region of the Russian Federation], 2016, available at:Ин... (accessed 19.02.2016).
15. Social'no-jekonomicheskoe razvitie Jurginskogo gorodskogo okruga za 2014 god [Socio-economic development of the city of Yurga district in 2014], 2014, available at:, p. 8 (accessed 19.02.2016).
16. Strategija social'no-jekonomicheskogo razvitija municipal'nogo obrazovanija goroda Naberezhnye Chelny do 2030 goda [Strategy of socio-economic development of the municipality of the city of Naberezhnye Chelny to 2030], 2015, available at: (accessed 19.02.2016).
17. Williamson, О. 1996, Jekonomicheskie instituty kapitalizma. Firmy, rynki, «otnoshencheskaja kontraktacija» [Economic Institutions of Capitalism. Firms, Markets, "relational contracting"], St. Petersburg, 702 p.
18. Ulyukayev, А. V. V 4 monogorodah budut sozdany territorii operezhajushhego razvitija… [The 4 single-industry towns will be created territory of priority development...], 2015, available atL (accessed 18.01.2016).
19. Sabirov, R., Idiyatullin, A., Gavrilenko, A. 2015, Челнинский ТОР благословлен... [Chelny TOP blessed... Chelninskij TOR blagoslovlen...], Delovaja jelektronnaja gazeta Biznes Online [Business e-Business Newspaper Online], available at: (accessed 19.02.2016).
20. Shastitko, А. Е. 2010, Novaja institucional'naja jekonomicheskaja teorija [New Institutional Economics], Moscow, 828 p.
21. Shastitko A., Fakhitova A. 2015, Monotowns: A New Take on the Old Problem, Balt. Reg. no. 1, p. 4—24. DOI: 10.5922/2079-8555-2015-1-1.
22. Boukendour, S. 2007, Preventing post-contractual opportunism by an option to switch from one contract to another, Construction management and economics, T. 25, Vol. 7, p. 723—727.
23. Drugov, M. 2010, Information and delay in an agency model, RAND Journal of Economics, T. 41, Vol. 3, p. 598—615.
24. Foss, N., Stea, D. 2014, Putting a Realistic Theory of Mind into Agency Theory: Implications for Reward Design and Management in Principal Agent Relations, European Management Review, T. 11, Vol. 1, p. 101—116.
25. Kaplan, T., Ruffle, B. 2011, Which way to cooperate, The Economic Journal, T. 122, Vol. 563, p. 1042—1068.
26. Parente, G., Shiklomanov, N., Streletskiy, D. 2012, Living in the New North: Migration to and from Russian Arctic Cities, Focus on Geography, T. 55, Vol. 3, p. 77—89.
27. Ramamohan Rao T. V. S. Estimating the parameters of Principal Agent Models, Journal of Quantitative Economics, T. 13, Vol. 1, p. 27—52.
28. Ronen, J., Yaari, V. 2007, Demand for the truth in principal-agent relationships, Review of accounting studies, T. 12, Vol. 1, p. 125—153.