Energy and the Ways of its Conceptualisation in Cognition: an Attempt at an Epistemological Analysis
- DOI
- 10.5922/2225-5346-2017-3-2
- Pages
- 30-59
Abstract
Thе article examines the connection between conceptualisation and transfer of knowledge in the humanities and analyses the role of these processes in the formation of conceptual and terminological framework for different types of discourse. The study draws on an analytical description of the development of the concept of energy in the Christian Orthodox discourse. The description was provided from the perspective of transferology — a new metadiscipline aimed to study the meaning-focused transformations of epistemological formations when transferred between different fields of knowledge. The author considers two types of transference — the explicit and implicit ones. In the former case, the genetic source of transferred epistemological formations — notions, concepts, terms, models, theoretical schemes, etc. — are known. In the latter case, the conceptual sources of the borrowed elements are unclear. The author addresses the need to develop a special epistemological discipline — conceptual comparative studies — aimed to analyse the ways of, and principles behind, the reality studied within discourses of various types.
Reference
1. Aristotel', 1999. Metafizika [Metaphysics]. Rostov-on-Don.
2. Bibikhin, V. V., 2005. Energy. Tochki — Puncta [Points — Puncta], 1—2(5), pp. 120—164.
3. Bibikhin, V. V., 2008. Vnutrennyaya forma slova [Internal form of a word]. St. Petersburg.
4. Bredshou, D., 2012. Aristotel' na Vostoke i na Zapade. Metafizika i razdelenie khristianskogo mira [Aristotle in the East and in the West. Metaphysics and the division of the Christian world]. Moscow.
5. Vasilii (Krivoshein), archbishop, 1996. Bogoslovskie trudy. 1952—1983 gg.: Stat'i, doklady, perevody [Theological works. 1952—1983: Articles, reports, translations]. Nizhny Novgorod.
6. Geronimus A., archpriest, 1995. Theology of sacred silence. In: S. S. Khoruzhii, ed. Sinergiya: Problemy asketiki i mistiki pravoslaviya [Synergy: Problems of asceticism and mysticism of Orthodoxy]. Moscow. pp. 151- 176.
7. Geronimus A., archpriest, 2003. Orthodox theology and the ways of fundamental science. In: Khristianstvo i nauka [Christianity and Science]. Moscow. pp. 208—256.
8. Geronimus A., archpriest, 2014. Rozhdenie ot Dukha. Chto znachit zhit' v pravoslavnom Predanii [Birth from the Spirit. What does it mean to live in Orthodox]. Moscow.
9. Grigorii Bogoslov, St., 1994. Sobranie tvorenii [Collection of creations.]. Sergiev Posad. Vol. 1.
10. Grigorii Palama, 1995. Triady v zashchitu svyashchennobezmolvstvuyushchikh [Triads in defense of the sacredly silent]. Moscow.
11. Grigorii Palama, 2007. Traktaty [Treatises]. Krasnodar.
12. Gumbol'dt, V. fon, 1984. Izbrannye trudy po yazykoznaniyu [Selected works on linguistics]. Moscow.
13. Davydenkov, O., archpriest, 1997. Dogmaticheskoe bogoslovie. Kurs lektsii [Dogmatic theology. Lecture course]. Moscow.
14. Davydenkov, O., archpriest, 2002. The concepts of "power" and "energy" in patristic theology. In: Davydenkov O., archpriest. Veliya blagochestiya taina: Bog yavisya vo ploti [Velia piety mystery: God appeared in the flesh]. Moscow. pp. 5—31.
15. Zhil'son, E. Dukh srednevekovoi filosofii: Giffordovskie lektsii [Spirit of medieval philosophy: Gifford lectures]. Moscow.
16. Zen'kovskii, V. V., 1991. Istoriya russkoi filosofii [History of Russian philosophy]. Leningrad. Vol. 2, part 2.
17. Ilarion (Alfeev), bishop, 2002. Svyashchennaya taina Tserkvi: Vvedenie v istoriyu i problematiku imyaslavskikh sporov [The sacred mystery of the Church: Introduction to the history and issues of the imyaslavsky controversies]. St. Petersburg.
18. Ioann (Ziziulas), metropolitan, 2006. Bytie kak obshchenie: Ocherki o lichnosti i Tserkvi [Existence as communion: Essays on the individual and the Church]. Moscow.
19. Lebedev, A. V., 1983. Act and potency. In: L. F. Il'ichev, P. N. Fedoseev, S. M. Kovalev, V. G. Panov, eds. Filosofskii entsiklopedicheskii slovar' [Philosophical encyclopedic dictionary]. Moscow. p. 17.
20. Lobanova, L. P., 2013. Kontseptsiya yazykovoi kartiny mira i ee istoki v trudakh Vil'gel'ma fon Gumbol'dta [The concept of the linguistic worldview and its origins in the works of Wilhelm von Humboldt]. Moscow.
21. Losev, A. F., 1993. Bytie — Imya — Kosmos [Existence — Name — Space]. Moscow.
22. Losev, A. F., 1994. Mif — Chislo — Sushchnost' [Myth — Number — Essence]. Moscow.
23. Losskii, V. N., 1991. Ocherk misticheskogo bogosloviya Vostochnoi Tserkvi. Dogmaticheskoe bogoslovie [Essay on the mystical theology of the Eastern Church. Dogmatic theology]. Moscow.
24. Losskii, V. N., 2000. Bogoslovie i Bogovidenie [Theology and Vision of God]. Moscow.
25. Losskii, V. N., 2013. Ocherk misticheskogo bogosloviya Vostochnoi Tserkvi. Dogmaticheskoe bogoslovie [Essay on the mystical theology of the Eastern Church. Dogmatic theology]. Sergiev Posad.
26. Meiendorf, I., protopresbyter, 1997. Zhizn' i trudy svyatitelya Grigoriya Palamy: Vvedenie v izuchenie [The life and works of St. Gregory Palama: Introduction to the study]. St. Petersburg.
27. Mikhailov, A. V., 1993. Instead of introduction. In: Khaidegger, M. Raboty i razmyshleniya raznykh let [Works and reflections of different years]. Moscow. pp. 7—52.
28. Obolevich, T., 2014. Ot imyaslaviya k estetike. Kontseptsiya simvola Alekseya Loseva. Istoriko- filosofskoe issledovanie [From imiaslavie to aesthetics. The concept of the symbol of Alexei Losev. Historical-philosophical study]. Moscow.
29. Blez, P., 1994. Mysli [Thoughts]. Moscow.
30. Il'ichev, L. F., Fedoseev, P. N., Kovalev, S. M., Panov, V. G., eds., 1983. Filosofskii entsiklopedicheskii slovar' [Philosophical encyclopedic dictionary]. Moscow. p. 487.
31. Plotin, 1995. Enneady [Enneads]. Kiev.
32. Postovalova, V. I., 2015. Faith. Culture. Language (Mystic-theological and metascientific views of Archpriest Alexander Geronimus). In: Yu. S. Vladimirova, ed. Khristianstvo i nauka: sbornik dokladov konferentsii [Christianity and science: collection of the conference papers]. Moscow. pp. 71—107.
33. Postovalova, V. I., 2016. Ways and principles of knowledge transfer in the humanities. In: V. F. Feshchenko, ed. Lingvistika i semiotika kul'turnykh transferov: metody, printsipy, tekhnologii [Linguistics and semiotics of cultural transfers: methods, principles, technologies]. Moscow. pp. 36—60.
34. Prokl, 1993. Pervoosnovy teologii; Gimny [The fundamental principles of theology; Hymns]. Moscow.
35. Radchenko, O. A., 1997. Yazyk kak mirosozidanie: Lingvofilosofskaya kontseptsiya neogumbol'dtianstva [Language as a world-creation: The linguistic-philosophical concept of the neogumboldtianism]. Moscow. Vol. 1.
36. Ramishvili, G. V., 1981. Linguistics in the range of human sciences. Voprosy yazykoznaniya [Issues of linguistics], 6, pp. 104—110.
37. Sofronii (Sakharov), archimandrite, 1985. Videt' Boga kak On est' [To see God as He is]. Essex.
38. Sofronii (Sakharov), archimandrite, 2000. Rozhdenie v Tsarstvo nepokolebimoe [Birth in the Kingdom unshakable]. Moscow.
39. Stepanov, Yu. S., 1995. Alternative world, Discourse, Fact and principle of Causality. In: Yu. S. Stepanov, ed. Yazyk i nauka kontsa 20 veka [Language and science of the late 20th century]. Moscow. pp. 35—73.
40. Florenskii, P. A., priest, 1996. Sochineniya [Works]. Moscow. Vol. 2.
41. Florenskii, P., priest, 1999. Sochineniya [Works]. Moscow. Vol. 3.
42. Florovskii, G., archpriest, 1992. Vostochnye ottsy IV veka [Eastern fathers of the IV century]. Moscow.
43. Florovskii, G., archpriest, 2002. Vera i kul'tura [Faith and culture]. St. Petersburg.
44. Khoruzhii, S. S., 1994. Posle pereryva. Puti russkoi filosofii [After the break. The ways of russian philosophy]. St. Petersburg.
45. Khoruzhii, S. S., 1995. Analytical dictionary of hesychast anthropology. In: S. S. Khoruzhii, ed. Sinergiya. Problemy asketiki i mistiki Pravoslaviya [Synergy. Problems of asceticism and mysticism of Orthodoxy]. Moscow. pp. 42—150.
46. Khoruzhii, S. S., 2000. O starom i novom [On the old and the new]. St. Petersburg.
47. Khoruzhii, S. S., 2005. Ocherki sinergiinoi antropologii [Essays on synergistic anthropology]. Moscow.
48. Khoruzhii, S. S., 2012. Issledovaniya po isikhastskoi traditsii. T. 2: K femenologii askezy [Research on hesychast tradition. Vol. 2: To the phenomenology of asceticism]. St. Petersburg.
49. Khoruzhii, S. S., 2015. Bibikhin, Khaidegger, Palama v probleme energii [Bibikhin, Heidegger, Palamas in the problem of energy]. Stasis, 3(11).
50. Tseller, E., 1996. Ocherk istorii grecheskoi filosofii [Essay on the history of Greek philosophy]. Moscow.
51. Il'ichev, L. F., Fedoseev, P. N., Kovalev, S. M., Panov, V. G., eds., 1983. Filosofskii entsiklopedicheskii slovar' [Philosophical encyclopedic dictionary]. Moscow. p. 800.