History in Transcription and Transcription as History: Charles Bally in Soviet Linguistics
- DOI
- 10.5922/2225-5346-2017-1-6
- Pages
- 62-83
Abstract
This article describes the results of a systemic study into the history of conveying the name of the Swiss linguist Charles Bally by the means of Russian transcription, in the 20th-century linguistic discussions. The author reconstructs the history of introducing Charles Bally’s works into Russian and Soviet linguistics, particularly, in the context of the publication of Ferdinand de Saussure’s Course of General Linguistics. The article analyses the variants of transcribing the name Bally in the works of G. O. Vinokur, M. N. Peterson, V. N. Voloshinov, G. K. Danilov, B. A. Larin, L. P. Yakubinsky, V. V. Vinogradov, and others. The author argues that the gradual codification of the Балли variant was a result of ideological discussions in Soviet linguistics held in the 1920—1950s.
Reference
1. Admoni, V. G., 1956. Development of the syntactic theory in the West in the ХХ century and structuralism. Voprosy yazykoznaniya [Questions of linguistics], 6, pp. 48—64.
2. Balli, Sh., 1995. Obshchaya lingvistika i voprosy frantsuzskogo yazyka [General linguistics and questions of the French language]. Moscow.
3. Balli, Sh., 1961. Frantsuzskaya stilistika [French stylistics]. Moscow.
4. Budagov, R., 1955. Sharl Balli and his work in general and french linguistics. In: Sh. Balli Obshchaya lingvistika i voprosy frantsuzskogo yazyka [General linguistics and questions of the French language]. Moscow
5. Bulakhovskii, L. A., 1952. Kurs russkogo literaturnogo yazyka [The course of the Russian literary language]. Kiev. Vol. 1.
6. Vinogradov, V. V., 1955. Results of discussion of stylistics issues. Voprosy yazykoznaniya [Questions of linguistics], 1. pp. 60—87.
7. Vinokur, G. O., 1923. Culture of language (Tasks of modern linguistics). Pechat' i revolyutsiya [Print and revolution], 5, pp. 100—111.
8. Vinokur, G. O., 1928. A verb or a name. Russkaya rech' [Russian speech], 3, pp. 75—93.
9. Vinokur, G. O., 1929. Kul'tura yazyka [Culture of language]. Moscow.
10. Vinokur, G. O., 1959. Izbrannye raboty po russkomu yazyku [Selected works on the Russian language]. Moscow.
11. Vislova, A. V., 1993. Stsenicheskoe tvorchestvo A. A. Mironova i problema stilya v akterskom iskusstve 60—80-kh godov [Scenic creativity of A. A. Mironov and the problem of style in the acting art of the 60s-80s], PhD. Moscow.
12. Voloshinov, V. N., 1928. The newest trends of linguistic thought in the west. Literatura i marksizm [Literature and marxism], 5, pp. 115—149.
13. Voloshinov, V. N., 1929. Marksizm i filosofiya yazyka [Marxism and the Philosophy of Language]. Leningrad.
14. Voloshinov, V. N., 1930. On the limits of poetics and linguistics. In: V. Desnitskii, L. Tsyrlin and N. Yakovlev, eds. V bor'be za marksizm v literaturnoi nauke [In the struggle for marxism in literary science]. Moscow. pp. 203—240.
15. Voloshinov, V. N., 1930. Marksizm i filosofiya yazyka [Marxism and the Philosophy of Language]. 2nd ed. Leningrad.
16. Gofman, V. A., 1936. Yazyk literatury: Ocherki i etyudy [Language of the literature: Essays and etudes]. Leningrad.
17. Gukovskii, G. A., 1946. Ocherki po istorii russkogo realizma. Ch. 1: Pushkin i russkie romantiki [Essays on the history of Russian realism. Part 1: Pushkin and the russian romantics]. Saratov.
18. Danilov, G. K., 1928. On the question of marxist linguistics. Literatura i marksizm [Literature and marxism], 6, pp. 115—137.
19. Danilov, G. K., 1929. The marxist method in lexicology. Russkii yazyk v sovetskoi shkole [Russian language in the Soviet school], 6, pp. 48—62.
20. Danilov, G. K., 1931. Kratkii ocherk istorii nauki o yazyke [A short essay on the history of the science of language]. Moscow.
21. Danilov, G. K. 1934. Linguists of the West. Za kommunisticheskoe prosveshchenie [For communist education], 222, p. 3.
22. The tasks of Soviet linguistics in the light of the works of I. V. Stalin and the journal “Questions of Linguistics”, 1952. Voprosy yazykoznaniya [Questions of Linguistics], 1, pp. 3—40.
23. Ivanov, V. V., 1954. J. Kurytowicz. L'accentuation des1 langues indoeuropéennes. Voprosy yazykoznaniya [Questions of Linguistics], 4, pp. 125—135.
24. Kartsevskii, S., 1928. Povtoritel'nyi kurs russkogo yazyka [Repeating course of Russian language]. Moscow.
25. Larin, B. A. On the linguistic study of the city. Russkaya rech’ [Russian speech], 3, pp. 61—74.
26. Loya, Ya., 1929. Voloshinov V. N. Marxism and the Philosophy of Language. Na literaturnom postu [At the literary post], 8, pp. 72—73.
27. Medvedev, P., 1928. Formal’nyi metod v literaturovedenii [Formal method in literary criticism]. Leningrad.
28. Musin-Pushkin, A. A., 1912. Sbornik statei po voprosam shkol'nogo obrazovaniya na Zapade i v Rossii (po lichnym nablyudeniyam) [Collection of articles on school education in the West and in Russia (on personal observations)]. St. Petersburg. Vol. 2.
29. Orlova, V. G., 1952. Discussion of the book of I. I. Meschaninov “Members of the proposals and the part of speech” at the enlarged meeting of the Academic council of the Institute of linguistics of the Academy of sciences of the USSR. Voprosy yazykoznaniya [Questions of Linguistics], 1, pp. 170—176.
30. Peterson, M. N., 1923. General linguistics. Pechat' i revolyutsiya [Print and Revolution], 6, pp. 26—32.
31. Peterson, M. N., 1927. Language as a social phenomenon. Uchenye zapiski Instituta yazyka i literatury RANION (Lingvisticheskaya sektsiya) [Scientific notes of the Institute of language and literature of RANION (Linguistic Section)], 1, pp. 5—21.
32. Piotrovskii, R. G., 1954. About some stylistic categories. Voprosy yazykoznaniya [Questions of Linguistics], 1, pp. 55—68.
33. Rozhdestvenskii, Yu. V., 1967. Semiotika i vostochnye yazyki [Semiotics and oriental languages]. Moscow.
34. Sossyur, F. de, 1916. Kurs obshchei lingvistiki, izdannyi Sharlem Baii i Al'bertom Seshegei v sotrudnichestve s Al'bertom Ridligerom. Lozanna, Paris.
35. Sossyur, F. de, 1933. Kurs obshchei lingvistiki [Course of general linguistics]. Moscow.
36. Sossyur, F. de, 1992. Kurs po obshcha lingvistika [Course of general linguistics]. Sofiya.
37. Teoriya literatury [Theory of Literature], 1965. Moscow. Vol. 3.
38. Shor, R. O., 1929. Voloshinov V. N. Marxism and the philosophy of language. The main problems of the sociological method in the science of language. Russkii
yazyk v sovetskoi shkole [Russian language in the Soviet school], 3, pp. 149—154.
39. Shpet, G. G., 2012. Filosof v kul’ture. Dokumenty i pis’ma [The philosopher in culture. Documents and letters]. Moscow.
40. Zheleznov V. Ya. and Kovalevskii, M. M., eds., 1930. Entsiklopedicheskii slovar’ Granat [Encyclopedic dictionary Granat]. Moscow. Vol. 41, part. 4.
41. Yakubinskii, L. P., 1931. F. de Sossyur on the impossibility of linguistic policy. Yazykovedenie i materialism [Linguistics and materialism], 2, pp. 91—104.
42. Yakubinskii, L. P., 1932. Against “danilovshchinya”. In: S. N. Bykovskii, ed. Protiv burzhuaznoi kontrabandy v yazykoznanii [Against bourgeois smuggling in linguistics]. Leningrad. pp. 47—65.
43. Amacker, R., 2000. Le développement des idées saussuriennes chez Bally et Sechahaye. Historiographia linguistica, 2—3, pp. 205—264.
44. Bally, Ch., 1905. Précis de stylistique. Geneva.
45. Bally, Ch., 1951. Traité de stylistique française. 3rd ed. Geneva, Paris.
46. Bally, Ch., 1935. Le langage et la vie. Genève. 3rd ed. Zurich.
47. Bally, Ch., 1950. Linguistique générale et linguistique française. Berne.
48. Saussure, F. de, 1916. Cours de linguistique générale publié par Charles Bally et Albert Sechehaye avec la collaboration de Albert Riedlinger. Lausanne, Paris.
49. Saussure, F. de, 1922. Cours de linguistique générale publié par Charles Bally et Albert Sechehaye avec la collaboration de Albert Riedlinger. Paris.
50. Velmezova, Е., 2006. Charles Bally au filtredesa réception en Russie. In: J.-L. Chiss, ed. Charles Bally (1865—1947): Historicité desdébats linguistiques et didactiques: Stylistique: Enonciation: CriseduFrançais. Louvain, Paris. pp. 41—51.