Search
Submit an article RU
The Baltic Region

Current issue

Back to the list Download the article
Filev M. V. Kurganskii A. A

Dismantling monuments as the core of the post-2014 ‘decommunisation’ in Ukraine and Poland

DOI
10.5922/2079-8555-2022-4-9
Pages
146-161
monument fall decommunisation politics of memory collective memory symbolic Policy Ukraine Poland

Abstract

Drawing on a wide range of sources (Polish and Ukrainian legal acts, Russian and international media), this study looks at the ‘monument fall’ in Ukraine and Poland as part of the post-2014 memory wars. The purpose of this article is to identify the main patterns associated with the demolition of Soviet and Russian monuments in the two countries. The ‘decommunisation’ of public space is an element of Ukraine’s and Poland’s politics of memory, enshrined in legal acts. Its driving force is the Institutes of National Remembrance, whose priorities include dismantling Soviet and pre-revolutionary Russian monuments, which came into full swing after the beginning of Russia’s special military operation to denazify and demilitarise Ukraine. The official narratives allot Poland and Ukraine the role of victims of ‘two aggressors’ in World War II, which found themselves under ‘communist occupation’. Therefore, the politics of memory of the two countries seek to get rid of the ‘Soviet legacy’ as the legacy of the ‘occupying country’. Whilst Poland pursues ‘residual decommunisation’ focused on dismantling the remaining memorials to Soviet soldiers-liberators, Ukraine is committed to transforming ‘decommunisation’ into full-scale ‘derussification’. At the same time, the process of ‘re-Sovietisation/Sovietisation’ has been launched in the liberated territories of Ukraine. It consists in restoring previously destroyed monuments or installing new ones.

Reference

1. Filippova, E. I. 2011, History and memory in the epoch of dominating identities: an interview with Pierre Nora, historian and member of the French Academy, Ethno review, № 4, p. 75—84 (in Russ.).

2. Repina, L. P. 2020, Historical memory and national narratives of identity: “the practice of history in the service of memory”, In: Repina, L. P. (ed.), The past for the present: history/memory and narratives of national identity, Moscow, Akvilon, p. 11—36 (in Russ.).

3. Malinova, O. Ju. 2018, Memory policy as a Symbolic policy area, In: Miller, A. I., Efremen­ko, D. V. (eds.), Methodological issues of studying the politics of memory, Moscow, Saint-Petersburg, Nestor-Istorija, p. 27—53 (in Russ.).

4. Kasianov, G. 2021, «Decommunisation» in Ukraine: 2014—2021: the process, actors, re­sults, Historical expertise, № 4, p. 174—200, https://doi.org/10.31754/2409-6105-2021-4-174-200 (in Russ.).

5. Miller, A. I., Efremenko, D. V. (eds.). 2018, Methodological issues of studying the politics of memory, Moscow, Saint-Petersburg, Nestor-Istorija, 224 р. (in Russ.).

6. Miller, A. I., Efremenko, D. V. (eds.). 2020, The politics of memory in contemporary Russia and in countries of Eastern Europe , Saint-Petersburg, Izd-vo Evropejskogo un-ta, 632 p. (in Russ.).

7. Lykoshina, L. S. 2015, The «historical politics» of modern Poland in the light of Russian-Polish relations, Slavic Almanac, № 1-2, p. 170—179 (in Russ.).

8. Bulahtin, M. A. 2019, Politics of historical memory in modern Poland, Bulletin of Udmurt University. Sociology. Political Science. International Relations, № 4, p. 449— 458, https://doi.org/10.35634/2587-9030-2019-3-4-449-458 (in Russ.).

9. Gajdaj, A. Ju., Liubaretc, A. V. 2016, Leninfall: elimination of the past as a way of construct­ing the future (on the materials of Dnepropetrovsk, Zaporozhye and Kharkov), Perm University Herald. History, № 2, p. 28—41, https://doi.org/10.17072/2219-3111-2016-2-28-41 (in Russ.).

10. Krinko, E. F., Hlynina, T. P. 2015, Ukraine without Lenin: old monuments and new ideology, Russian regions: looking into the future, № 1, p. 40—57 (in Russ.).

11. Plehanov, A. A. 2018, Decommunization process in post-Soviet Ukraine, Political Science, № 3, p. 190—216 (in Russ.), https://doi.org/10.31249/poln/2018.03.10.

12. Plehanov, A. A. 2017, Ukrainian decommunization: the struggle for symbol­ic domination? In: Politicheskoe soznanie, povsednevnye praktiki, novye identichnosti, Materialy mezhdunarodnoj konferencii [Constructing the “Soviet”? political conscious­ness, everyday practices, new identities: proceedings of the international conference], Saint-Petersburg, p. 131—138 (in Russ.).

13. Kasianov, G. V. 2019, Ukraina i sosedi: istoricheskaja politika. 1987—2018, [Ukraine and neighbors: Historical politics. 1987—2018], Moscow, NLO, 282 p. (in Russ.).

14. Grytsenko, O. 2019, Decommunization in Ukraine as a public policy and as a cultural phenomenon, Kyiv, Іnstitut polіtichnih і etnonacіonal’nih doslіdzhen’ іm. І. F. Kurasa NAN Ukraїni; Іnstitut kul’turologії NAM Ukraїni, 320 p. (in Ukr.).

15. Kasianov, G. 2021, Ukraine as a “Nationalizing State”: A Review of Practices and Out­comes , Sociology of Power, vol. 3, № 2, p. 117—146, https://doi.org/10.22394/2074-0492-2021-2-117-146 (in Russ.).

16. Lykoshina, L. S. 2017, The image of Russia as a factor in the formation of national identity in the socio-political discourse of modern Poland, In: Makarov, N. A. (ed), Rossiya v pol’skoi istoriografii, Pol’sha v rossiiskoi istoriografii (k 50-letiyu Komissii istorikov Rossii i Pol’shi) [Russia in Polish Historiography, Poland in Russian Historiography (for the 50th anniversary of the Commission of Historians of Russia and Poland)], Moscow, Indrik, p. 130—144 (in Russ.).

17. Kasyanov, G. 2016, Historical policy and the «memorial» laws in Ukraine: the beginning of the 21st century, Historical expertise, № 2, p. 28—55 (in Russ.).

18. Levchenkov, A. S. 2019, The «Policy of Memory» in the context of Ukraine’s foreign policy in 2014 — Early 2019, Russia and the contemporary world, № 4, p. 111— 126, https://doi.org/10.31249/rsm/2019.04.07 (in Russ.).

19. Ivanov, G. 2019, «Suvorov — on the way out». How Ukraine continues the war with monuments, Argumenty i fakty, available at: https://aif.ru/politics/world/suvor­ov_na_vyhod_kak_ukraina_prodolzhaet_voynu_s_pamyatnikami_i_zdravym (accessed 09.05.2022) (in Russ.).

20. Kulemjakin, D. 2022, The Kiev authorities have proposed to demolish 60 monuments associated with Russia, Rossijskaja gazeta, available at: https://rg.ru/2022/04/25/vlasti-kieva-pred­lozhili-snesti-60-pamiatnikov-sviazannyh-s-rossiej.html (accessed 09.05.2022) (in Russ.).

21. Tolochko, P. P. (ed.). 2018, Istorija Ukrainy. XVI—XXI vv. [History of Ukraine. XVI—XXI centuries], Kyiv, Moscow, Kievskaja Rus’; Kuchkovo pole, 472 p. (in Russ.).

22. Kasyanov, G., Miller, A. 2011, Russia — Ukraine: the Way History Gets Written. Dialogues — Lectures — Articles, Moscow, Izd-vo RGGU, 311 p. (in Russ.).

23. Stojakin, V. 2022, How memory was killed. The hard fate of war monuments in Ukraine, Ukraina.Ru, available at: https://ukraina.ru/exclusive/20220508/1033888378.html (accessed 12.06.2022) (in Russ.).

24. Korf, A. 2022, In the liberated cities, previously dismantled sculptures began to be returned, Readovka.Ru, available at: https://readovka.news/news/94201 (accessed 11.06.2022) (in Russ.).

25. Panchenko, L. 2022, Russian and Soviet monuments will be restored and returned to their place in the DPR, Moskovskij komsomolec, available at: https://www.mk.ru/poli­tics/2022/05/07/v-dnr-vosstanovyat-i-vozvratyat-na-mesta-rossiyskie-i-sovetskie-pamyatniki.html (accessed 09.05.2022) (in Russ.).

26. Nagornyh, O. V. 2020, The politics of memory in the process of decommunization in Po­land, Etnosoсium (multinational society), № 7, p. 86—97 (in Russ.).

27. Rokossovskaja, A. 2017, Out of sight — out of mind? Rossijskaja gazeta, available at: https://rg.ru/2017/09/13/rodina-o-snose-pamiatnikov.html (accessed 01.07.2022) (in Russ.).

28. Dudek, A. 2008, Disputes over Polish historical policy after 1989, Pamięć i polityka historyczna. Doświadczenia Polski i jej sąsiadów, p. 33—57 (in Pol.).

29. Slovinski, K. 2020, The Historical Policy of Poland’s Law and Justice Party, Sovremennaya Evropa, № 1, p. 102—113, http://dx.doi.org/10.15211/soveurope12020102112 (in Russ.).

30. Bukonkin, D. A. 2016, Historical politics as a new element in the Belarusian-Polish interstate relations. In: Mnogovektornost’ vo vneshnej politike Respubliki Belarus’, Materialy mezhdunarodnyh kruglyh stolov [Multi-vector in the foreign policy of the Republic of Belarus: materials of international round tables], Minsk, p. 4—15 (in Russ.).

31. Bajnazarov, Je. 2021, Tolerable character: Warsaw dismantled six monuments to Red Army soldiers, Izvestija, available at: https://iz.ru/1152030/elnar-bainazarov/snosnyi-kharakter-varsha­va-demontirovala-shest-pamiatnikov-krasnoarmeitcam (ac­cessed 04.07.2022) (in Russ.).

32. Miller, A. I. 2022, National identity in Ukraine: history and politics, Russia in Global Affairs, № 4, p. 46—65, https://doi.org/10.31278/1810-6374-2022-20-3-94-114 (in Russ.).