Non-expansionist variants of Poland's strategic culture: a retrospective of ideas and current implications
- DOI
- 10.5922/2079-8555-2022-2-5
- Pages
- 69-82
Abstract
This article examines how non-expansionist types of strategic culture emerged and gradually developed in Poland. The study aims to identify the features of non-expansionist types of Polish strategic culture for a more objective analysis of the country's modern foreign and security policy. The article begins by describing the emergence and use of the concept of strategic culture, offering a typology of strategic cultures based on the work of the 'cultural realist' Alastair Johnston. Then it employs a qualitative method of process tracing to outline the sequence of events and the ideological constructs that led to the emergence or degradation of the corresponding types of strategic culture. The strategic culture of neutrality, exposed to external influences and revised republicanism ideas, is shown to have laid the foundation for a strategic culture of political fortification (or an outpost) in Poland. This strategic culture has its origins in the idea of the ethical superiority of the Polish state, although the details of this superiority may differ dramatically in specific situations. At the same time, none of the types of the accommodation culture has yet emerged in Poland, albeit accommodation seems to be a promising lead for the further development of the country’s strategic culture.
Reference
1. Snyder, J. L. 1977, The Soviet Strategic Culture: Implications for Limited Nuclear Operations, Washington, RAND Corporation.
2. Gray, C. S. 1999, Modern Strategy. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 426 р.
3. Legro, J. W. 1996, Culture and preferences in the international cooperation two-step, American Political Science Review, vol. 90, № 1, p. 118—137.
4. Sondhaus, L. 2006, Strategic culture and ways of war, London, Routledge.
5. Glenn, J. 2009, Realism versus strategic culture: Competition and collaboration? International Studies Review, vol. 11, № 3, p. 523—551.
6. Lantis, J. S. 2002, Strategic culture and national security policy, International Studies Review, vol. 4, № 3, p. 87—113.
7. Alekseeva, T. A. 2012, Strategic Culture: Concept Evolution, Polis. Politicheskie issledovaniya [Policy. Political Studies], № 5, p. 130—147 (in Russ.).
8. Bloomfield, A. 2012, Time to move on: Reconceptualizing the strategic culture debate, Contemporary Security Policy, vol. 33, № 3, p. 437—461.
9. Wilson, R. W. 2000, The Many Voices of Political Culture: Assessing Different Approaches, World Politics, vol. 52, № 2, p. 246—273.
10. Lantis, J. S., Charlton, A. A. 2011, Continuity or change? The strategic culture of Australia, Comparative Strategy, vol. 30, № 4, p. 291—315.
11. Rasmussen, M. V. 2005, ‘What’s the use of it?’: Danish strategic culture and the utility of armed force, Cooperation and Conflict, vol. 40, № 1, p. 67—89.
12. Doeser, F. 2018, Historical experiences, strategic culture, and strategic behavior: Poland in the anti-ISIS coalition, Defence Studies, vol. 18, № 4, p. 454—473.
13. Doeser, F., Eidenfalk, J. 2019, Using strategic culture to understand participation in expeditionary operations: Australia, Poland, and the coalition against the Islamic State, Contemporary Security Policy, vol. 40, № 1, p. 4—29.
14. Vislenko A. L. 2014, National idea: justifying the future or justifying the present, Vestnik Tomskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Kul’turologiya i iskusstvovedenie [Bulletin of Tomsk State University. Cultural studies and art history], № 3 (15), p. 5—13 (in Russ.).
15. Shimov, Ya. V. 2019, Intermarium: the space of fate, Istoricheskaya ekspertiza [historical expertise], № 3 (20), p. 79—97 (in Russ.).
16. Piekarski, M. 2019, Polska kultura strategiczna a wizerunek żołnierza polskiego w kulturze współczesnej, Bezpieczeństwo. Obronność. Socjologia, № 11/12, s. 7—29.
17. Zarobny, S. 2020, Changes in Polish Strategic Culture in the Context of Challenges and Threats of the 21st Century, Security Dimensions. International and National Studies, № 34, p. 122—144.
18. Johnston, A. I. 1998, Cultural realism: Strategic culture and grand strategy in Chinese history, Princeton Princeton University Press.
19. Frost, R. I. 2014, The northern wars: war, state and society in northeastern Europe, 1558—1721, London—New York, Routledge.
20. Nowak, A. 2020, Między nieładem a niewolą. Krótka historia myśli politycznej, Kraków, Biały Kruk.
21. Shchaveleva, N. I. 1990, Polish Latin-language medieval sources. Texts, translation, commentary. М., Nauka (in Russ.).
22. Rzeczycki, M. 2019, Własność i władza. Ujęcie własności ziemi w myśli Stanisława Zaborowskiego, Dialogi Polityczne, № 26, s. 27—37.
23. Topolski, J. 2015, Rzeczpospolita Obojga Narodów, 1501—1795, Wydawnictwo Poznań, Poznańskie.
24. Gierszewski, M. 2020, O rektorze w cycerońskiej koncepcji rzeczypospolitej oraz recepcji jego filozofii politycznej w Rzeczypospolitej Polskiej XVI wieku, Dialogi Polityczne, № 28, s. 111—139.
25. Pietrzyk-Reeves, D. 2010, O pojęciu” Rzeczpospolita”(res publica) w polskiej myśli politycznej XVI wieku, Czasopismo Prawno-Historyczne, vol. 62, № 1, s. 37—63.
26. Demyanovsky, N. A. 2015, The political structure of the Commonwealth through the eyes of publicists at the end of the 18th century, Vestnik Tverskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Seriya: Istoriya [Bulletin of the Tver State University. Series: History], № 4, p. 116—125 (in Russ.).
27. Osipova, E. V. 1961, Filosofiya pol’skogo Prosveshcheniya [Philosophy of the Polish Enlightenment], M., Publishing House of the Academy of Sciences of the USSR (in Russ.).
28. Nosow, B. W. 2000, Stanislaw Staszic—ostatnia przestroga dla Polski, Napis. Pismo poświęcone literaturze okolicznościowej i użytkowej, № 6, s. 239—243.
29. Rolnik, D. 2021, Idea państwa wolnego, suwerennego i niepodległego—fenomen przemian czasów Sejmu Czteroletniego? Roczniki Humanistyczne, vol. 69, № 2, s. 29— 48.
30. Ivonina, L. I. 2020, Yarkii zakat Rechi Pospolitoi: Yan Sobesskii, Avgust Sil’nyi, Stanislav Leshchinskii [Bright sunset of the Commonwealth: Jan Sobieski, August Strong, Stanislav Leshchinsky], M.-SPb., Nestor-History.
31. Denisov, Yu. N. 2019, Rossiya i Pol’sha: istoriya vzaimootnoshenii v XVII—XX vv. [Russia and Poland: the history of relations in the XVII—XX centuries], M., FLINT.
32. Smirnov, A. F. 1962, Revolyutsionnye svyazi narodov Rossii i Pol’shi. 30—60 gody XIX veka [Revolutionary ties between the peoples of Russia and Poland. 30—60 years of the XIX century], M., Publishing house of socio-economic literature (in Russ.).
33. Gamulka, K. 2008, Pamіzh Pol’shchai і Rasіyai: Belarus’ u kantseptsyyakh pol’skіkh palіtychnykh farmіravannyaў (1918—1922) [Former Poland and Russia: Belarus at the Chancesption of Polish Pharmaceutical Pharmaceuticals (1918—1922)], Translation from Polish language, Vilnia, YSU (in Ukr.).
34. Kornat, M. 2017, Realizm polityczny i imponderabilia. Józef Piłsudski i jego pojmowanie polskiej racji stanu na arenie międzynarodowej, Annales Universitatis Paedagogicae Cracoviensis Studia Politologica, vol. 17, № 214, s. 61—79.
35. Rzegocki, A. 2008, Racja stanu a polska tradycja myślenia o polityce, Kraków, Ośrodek Myśli Politycznej.
36. Lykoshina, L. S. 2015, “Historical politics” of modern Poland in the context of Russian-Polish relations, Slavyanskii al’manakh [Slavic almanac], № 1—2, p. 170—179 (in Russ.).